(BUTTON) All Sections (BUTTON) Search [diplomat_logo_black.jpg] Read The Diplomat, Know The Asia-Pacific (BUTTON) My Account Sign In Subscribe Central Asia East Asia Oceania South Asia Southeast Asia | Security Politics Diplomacy Economy Society Environment | DRI Magazine | All Regions * Central Asia * East Asia * Oceania * South Asia * Southeast Asia Topics * Diplomacy * Economy * Environment * Opinion * Politics * Security * Society Blogs * ASEAN Beat * Asia Defense * Asia Life * China Power * Crossroads Asia * Flashpoints * Oceania * Pacific Money * The Debate * The Koreas * The Pulse * Tokyo Report * Trans-Pacific View More * Features * Interviews * Photo Essays * Podcasts * Risk Intelligence * Videos MagazineThe Asia-Pacific in 2021: What to Expect? January 2021 The Asia-Pacific in 2021: What to Expect? The Diplomat * Home Page * About Us * Contact Us * Write for Us * * Advertise * Syndicate * Privacy * Newsletter * Subscriptions The Debate Will India Become the Home of the Largest Number of Stateless People? Recent Features How Biden Can Navigate a New Era in South Korean Politics Diplomacy How Biden Can Navigate a New Era in South Korean Politics India’s Invisible Women Farmers Society India’s Invisible Women Farmers Can Singapore Keep Its Precious Hawker Culture Alive? Society Can Singapore Keep Its Precious Hawker Culture Alive? J-20: The Stealth Fighter That Changed PLA Watching Forever Security J-20: The Stealth Fighter That Changed PLA Watching Forever Dhanushkodi Fisherfolk: 50 Years of Life on the Edge Photo Essays Dhanushkodi Fisherfolk: 50 Years of Life on the Edge What If the Afghan Peace Process Fails? Security What If the Afghan Peace Process Fails? ‘Global Britain’: The UK in the Indo-Pacific Diplomacy ‘Global Britain’: The UK in the Indo-Pacific What Are Asian Governments Saying About the Storming of the US Capitol? Diplomacy What Are Asian Governments Saying About the Storming of the US Capitol? Uyghurs Wary of Turkey’s Pending Extradition Deal With China Diplomacy Uyghurs Wary of Turkey’s Pending Extradition Deal With China What Is the Truth About COVID-19 in North Korea? Economy What Is the Truth About COVID-19 in North Korea? 6 Suggestions for Biden’s China Policy Diplomacy 6 Suggestions for Biden’s China Policy The Strategic Implications of the China-EU Investment Deal Diplomacy The Strategic Implications of the China-EU Investment Deal The Debate Will India Become the Home of the Largest Number of Stateless People? International pressure to ensure India fully respects the rights of all its people is urgently needed. By Rudabeh Shahid, Champa Patel and Ravi Hemadri for The Diplomat August 30, 2019 Will India Become the Home of the Largest Number of Stateless People? People whose names were left out in the National Register of Citizens (NRC) draft stand in a queue to collect forms to file appeals near a NRC center on the outskirts of Gauhati, India, Monday, Aug. 13, 2018. Credit: AP Photo/Anupam NathAdvertisement On August 5, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), India’s ruling party, controversially stripped the state of Jammu and Kashmir of its autonomy. Prime Minister Narendra Modi and the Hindu-nationalist BJP have long argued that Muslim-majority Kashmir should not have special status and that the state was marred by terrorism and corruption. This development highlights the prevalence of Hindu-Muslim inter-communal tensions since the BJP took office in 2014. While the focus on Kashmir is important, international attention on this issue is masking the ongoing disenfranchisement of a large Muslim population in Assam, a state in northeastern India. The National Register of Citizens (NRC) process has put almost 4 million people, largely Bengali Muslims, at risk of being made stateless. The UN High Commissioner for Refugees estimates that there are 10 million stateless people worldwide. With this one act, India risks becoming the home of the largest number of stateless people in the world. What Led to the NRC? Anti-immigration sentiments have lingered in Assam for decades, the roots of which can be traced back to India’s colonial history. After the British conquered the region in 1826, they drastically altered Assam’s demographic structure. The immigration of Bengalis from neighboring East Bengal was incentivized as the British needed workers for their agrarian base. In 1983, hundreds of Bengali Muslims were killed by Assamese nationalists during a massacre in Nellie, central Assam. Since then, there remains deep friction between these ethnic groups, affecting Assamese society to this day. Diplomat Brief Weekly Newsletter N Get briefed on the story of the week, and developing stories to watch across the Asia-Pacific. Get the Newsletter In 1985, Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi signed an accord with Assamese nationalists to create a citizenship register. According to this register, anyone who entered India after midnight of March 24, 1971 (the day before Bangladesh declared its independence) was considered a foreigner. However, no real advances were made on the registry until its revival in the summer of 2018. Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month. Failures of the NRC process When the BJP campaigned for state elections in 2016, its manifesto was to publish the NRC as soon as possible. When the first draft of the NRC was published in the summer of 2018, it was revealed that more than 12 percent of the Assam population, or almost 4 million people (mainly of Bengali ethnicity and largely Muslim) didn’t make the cut. It is expected that the final NRC list, which is scheduled to be published on August 31, will have roughly the same number of people omitted. The NRC process is a highly bureaucratic and paper-based exercise. Applicants must produce proof of their family’s residence in Assam prior to 1971. Having such documentation is difficult in Assam, where 30 percent of the population are illiterate and live below the poverty line. In some cases, even army personnel have not found their names on the NRC list. This process contradicts international norms where the burden of nationality determination lies with the state not the individual. Advertisement Procedural problems are also prevalent, for example instances where identities are mixed up because people share similar names; confusion due to multiple marriages within the Muslim community; and simple clerical errors to names, dates, and ages. In addition, many people have lost documentation as a result of displacement from flooding, river erosion, and ethnic violence over the years. The government has announced that those excluded from the NRC will have 120 days to appeal their cases and establish Indian citizenship in front of the appellate authority, locally known as Foreigner Tribunals. The tribunals have been criticized for being opaque and arbitrary in their proceedings and have been marred by errors. Furthermore, there is no legal provision exempting children from standing trial. UN Rapporteurs have also commented that the lack of clarity between different processes (not just the NRC process, but also electoral roll information and separate judicial processes before the Tribunals) leads to the risk of arbitrary and biased decision-making. This is further reinforced by the BJP’s current efforts to pass the Citizenship Amendment Bill 2016, which makes it easier for immigrants from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan to obtain citizenship – as long as they are not Muslim. This clearly discriminatory bill, however, puts the BJP in tension with state officials and pressure groups in Assam who don’t want any Bengali “foreigners,” whatever their religion. Lastly, delays could leave people living in limbo with their citizenship status in doubt for months, if not years, as appeals through the High Court and Supreme Court take place. Faced with such an abject situation, some residents have died by suicide and high rates of negative mental health have been reported. The NRC and Potential Statelessness The impending statelessness catastrophe in Assam has been seen before. In the 1980s the Bhutanese government stripped the Lhotshampas, a Nepali ethnic group, of their citizenship and forced them to leave the country. More recently, the Rohingyas, a stateless and mostly Muslim ethnic group residing in Myanmar, fled to Bangladesh after a wave of attacks. Thousands of individuals in Assam are already in detention camps after having their citizenship questioned. Several new detention camps are being readied to house those expected to become stateless at the end of the month. Already dealing with the Rohingya crisis on one border, Bangladesh has expressly stated that it will not accept those India deems “foreign.” The risk of indefinite detention without any recourse looms large. Furthermore, the NRC deadline coincides with the constitutional amendments on Kashmir, begging the question: Is the BJP’s plan to keep the focus on Kashmir to ensure little scrutiny of what is happening in Assam? Enjoying this article? Click here to subscribe for full access. Just $5 a month. As the world’s largest democracy, India paints itself on the international stage as a supporter of international norms and rule of law. But such talk is shallow if India is not held accountable for its actions. In 2017 the world was shocked at the brutality suffered by one million Rohingyas who fled violence unleashed by the Burmese military junta. A new statelessness crisis is looming in South Asia, which could affect almost 4 million people. International pressure to ensure there is due process and clarity on what happens after the NRC deadline is essential. India must safeguard the rights of all its people or the human costs will be incalculable. Rudabeh Shahid is an upcoming postdoctoral fellow at the University of York, Champa Patel is Head of Asia-Pacific at Chatham House and Ravi Hemadri is Executive Director, Development and Justice Initiative. Tags * The Debate * Assam * Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) * BJP * India * National Register of Citizens * NRC * NRC India * stateless persons COVID-19 In Asia C Australia Debates Vaccines, Worries About New COVID-19 Strain January 13, 2021 Australia Debates Vaccines, Worries About New COVID-19 Strain Jokowi Receives First Shot as Indonesia Begins CoronaVac Roll-out January 13, 2021 Jokowi Receives First Shot as Indonesia Begins CoronaVac Roll-out China’s Ambitious COVID-19 Vaccine Targets January 07, 2021 China’s Ambitious COVID-19 Vaccine Targets Multimedia M Elections in Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan: What Next? January 14, 2021 Elections in Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan: What Next? Sky High: How the Asia-Pacific Sees Space January 13, 2021 Sky High: How the Asia-Pacific Sees Space Dhanushkodi Fisherfolk: 50 Years of Life on the Edge January 11, 2021 Dhanushkodi Fisherfolk: 50 Years of Life on the Edge Interview I Slow Anti-Americanism in Central Asia January 12, 2021 Slow Anti-Americanism in Central Asia By Catherine Putz “U.S. power can inadvertently shift politics even in regions like Central Asia where the United States is remote.” Magazine M North Korea Without Nukes: How Does It Measure Up? January 01, 2021 North Korea Without Nukes: How Does It Measure Up? Vietnam’s Coming Leadership Change January 01, 2021 Vietnam’s Coming Leadership Change The Future of US-India Digital Relations January 01, 2021 The Future of US-India Digital Relations The Asia-Pacific in 2021: What to Expect January 01, 2021 The Asia-Pacific in 2021: What to Expect DRI | COVID-19 IN ASIA Presented by Diplomat Risk Intelligence Australia Debates Vaccines, Worries About New COVID-19 Strain January 13, 2021 Australia Debates Vaccines, Worries About New COVID-19 Strain By Joshua Mcdonald The emergence of a much more contagious variant of COVID-19 comes as Australia rolls out vaccines. Jokowi Receives First Shot as Indonesia Begins CoronaVac Roll-out January 13, 2021 Jokowi Receives First Shot as Indonesia Begins CoronaVac Roll-out By Sebastian Strangio The announcement comes as confirmed COVID-19 infections continue to spike across the archipelago. China’s Ambitious COVID-19 Vaccine Targets January 07, 2021 China’s Ambitious COVID-19 Vaccine Targets By Eleanor Albert With its first homegrown vaccine approved for general use, China aims to vaccinate 50 million people by the Lunar New Year in February. What Is the Truth About COVID-19 in North Korea? January 06, 2021 What Is the Truth About COVID-19 in North Korea? By Mitch Shin North Korea insists there have been no coronavirus cases in the country. So why does it keep tightening restrictions, despite the heavy cost? Related R (Dis)integrating Muslims, Dismantling India December 30, 2019 (Dis)integrating Muslims, Dismantling India By Muqtedar Khan India, where Muslims have been at home for more than a millennium, is trying its hardest to alienate, disenfranchise, and disintegrate them. The NRC and India’s Unfinished Partition October 03, 2019 The NRC and India’s Unfinished Partition By Grant Wyeth The ongoing ideological struggle over Indian nationhood surfaced with Assam’s National Register of Citizens. RSS vs RCEP: Explaining Hindu Nationalists’ Opposition to RCEP December 28, 2020 RSS vs RCEP: Explaining Hindu Nationalists’ Opposition to RCEP By Krzysztof Iwanek The wide array of Indian groups opposing RCEP included the Hindu nationalist organization behind the ruling party. How Will COVID-19 Impact the BJP’s Electoral Chances? May 19, 2020 How Will COVID-19 Impact the BJP’s Electoral Chances? By Aditi Dayal The COVID-19 pandemic has altered the political dynamics in India -- how much will it matter? Features F How Biden Can Navigate a New Era in South Korean Politics January 15, 2021 How Biden Can Navigate a New Era in South Korean Politics By Brian Kim The future of U.S.-ROK relations depends on the United States understanding the priorities of South Korea’s now-dominant liberals. India’s Invisible Women Farmers January 14, 2021 India’s Invisible Women Farmers By Neeta Lal The farmers' protests outside New Delhi have cast a spotlight on a traditionally overlooked group: the women who keep India's farms running. Can Singapore Keep Its Precious Hawker Culture Alive? January 13, 2021 Can Singapore Keep Its Precious Hawker Culture Alive? By Ashley Tan Singapore’s hawker culture has been recognized by UNESCO, but there are questions about its sustainability. J-20: The Stealth Fighter That Changed PLA Watching Forever January 11, 2021 J-20: The Stealth Fighter That Changed PLA Watching Forever By Rick Joe A decade after the J-20's maiden flight, a look back at China's fifth generation stealth fighter – and how it changed PLA watching forever. DRI | APAC Risks, Analyzed DRI Elections in Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan: What Next? January 14, 2021 Elections in Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan: What Next? By Ankit Panda A presidential election in Kyrgyzstan and a parliamentary election in Kazakhstan kick off 2021 in Central Asia. China-EU Investment Deal Sparks Backlash Over Rights Concerns January 13, 2021 China-EU Investment Deal Sparks Backlash Over Rights Concerns By Shannon Tiezzi Civil society organizations and members of the European Parliament alike are objecting to the deal amid China's continuing crackdowns in Xinjiang and Hong Kong. The Unending Saga of India’s Retrospective Tax Debacle January 05, 2021 The Unending Saga of India’s Retrospective Tax Debacle By Abhishek Dwivedi India finally has an investor-friendly image after almost a decade and should strive to maintain that. Indonesia’s Nuclear Dream, Revived? December 31, 2020 Indonesia’s Nuclear Dream, Revived? By Sung-Mi Kim Does the Joko Widodo government have nuclear aspirations? Blogs B The Makwanpur Model: Making Public Healthcare in Nepal Work January 15, 2021 The Makwanpur Model: Making Public Healthcare in Nepal Work By Chitij Karki and Harsh Mahaseth Administrative decentralization has led to a vast improvement in the delivery of healthcare in Nepal. This is one district’s story. Biden’s Cabinet Picks Will Hold India-US Relations in Steady Course January 15, 2021 Biden’s Cabinet Picks Will Hold India-US Relations in Steady Course By Saba Sattar A move away from “America First” stands to help deepen security relations between the two countries. Earthquake Sets off Landslides, Flattens Homes in Indonesia January 15, 2021 Earthquake Sets off Landslides, Flattens Homes in Indonesia By Associated Press At least 10 people have so far been confirmed dead and more than 200 injured. North Korea Holds Huge Military Parade as Kim Vows Nuclear Might January 15, 2021 North Korea Holds Huge Military Parade as Kim Vows Nuclear Might By Associated Press The parade, which included a new submarine-launched ballistic missile, closed out the eight-day Workers' Party congress. Regions * Central Asia * East Asia * Oceania * South Asia * Southeast Asia Topics * Diplomacy * Economy * Environment * Opinion * Politics * Security * Society Blogs * ASEAN Beat * Asia Defense * Asia Life * China Power * Crossroads Asia * Flashpoints * Oceania * Pacific Money * The Debate * The Koreas * The Pulse * Tokyo Report * Trans-Pacific View More * Features * Interviews * Photo Essays * Podcasts * Risk Intelligence * Videos Archives * A New Japan * By Other Means * APAC Insider * Asia Scope * China, What's Next? * Indian Decade * James Holmes * New Emissary * New Leaders Forum * Sport & Culture * Tech Biz * Tokyo Notes * Zachary Keck The Diplomat * About Us * Contact Us * Write for Us * Partners * Advertise * Syndicate * Privacy Policy * Newsletters * Subscriptions MagazineThe Asia-Pacific in 2021: What to Expect? January 2021 The Asia-Pacific in 2021: What to Expect? © 2021 Diplomat Media Inc. All Rights Reserved.