#Vox Skip to main content Cookie banner We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our site, show personalized content and targeted ads, analyze site traffic, and understand where our audiences come from. To learn more or opt-out, read our Cookie Policy. Please also read our Privacy Notice and Terms of Use, which became effective December 20, 2019. By choosing I Accept, you consent to our use of cookies and other tracking technologies. (BUTTON) I Accept Vox homepage Follow Vox online: * * * * Site search (BUTTON) Search Search Vox main menu * The Biden Transition * Coronavirus * Open Sourced * Recode * The Goods * Future Perfect * The Highlight * First Person * Crossword * Podcasts * Video * Explainers * Culture * Politics & Policy * Science & Health * World * Identities * Technology * Energy & Environment * Business & Finance * More ____________________ Search * The Biden Transition * Coronavirus * Open Sourced * Recode * The Goods * Future Perfect * The Highlight * First Person * Crossword * Podcasts * Video * Explainers * Culture * Politics & Policy * Science & Health * World * Identities * Technology * Energy & Environment * Business & Finance (BUTTON) ✕ Support our journalism Millions rely on Vox’s explainers to understand an increasingly chaotic world. Chip in as little as $3 to help keep Vox free for all. (BUTTON) × The partisan culture war over masks One conservative writer’s viral rant explains how a basic public health measure become another front in the culture wars. By Zack Beauchamp@zackbeauchamp May 13, 2020, 1:50pm EDT Share this story * Share this on Facebook * Share this on Twitter * Share All sharing options Share All sharing options for: The partisan culture war over masks * Reddit * Pocket * Flipboard * Email A nurse counter-protesting against lockdown demonstrators in Minnesota. Aaron Lavinsky/Star Tribune/Getty Images Wearing a mask is one of the easiest ways to contribute to the fight against coronavirus. Infected people wearing masks are less likely to spray virus-containing droplets onto others, which means that universal mask-wearing should, in theory, make everyone safer. There’s some evidence from across the world that suggests the widespread use of masks has played a role in reducing coronavirus transmission. Studies on mask-wearing generally support it, finding that masks generally provide at least some protection. At worst, masks are a low-cost intervention that might help at the margins. But in recent weeks, mask-wearing in the United States has become another flashpoint in the partisan culture wars. President Trump refuses to wear a mask in public appearances — including one at a factory that produces masks — or in his office, despite a recent outbreak among the White House staff. Vice President Mike Pence opted not to wear one when he visited the Mayo Clinic, a prominent medical facility in Minnesota that’s treating coronavirus patients. Many Republicans in Congress have opted not to wear masks on the House and Senate floors, despite several members of their caucus testing positive for the illness earlier this spring. People tend to take signals from their political leadership, and rank-and-file Republicans appear to have gotten the message. New research from three political scientists — Syracuse’s Shana Gadarian, UC-Irvine’s Sara Goodman, and Cornell’s Tom Pepinsky — analyzed polling data on over 2,400 Americans’ attitudes and self-reported behaviors during the pandemic. They find that, after controlling for “a full set” of confounding variables, partisanship is a fairly strong predictor of one’s likelihood of wearing a mask. “Democrats are more than 20 percentage points more likely than Republicans to (75% versus 53%) to report wearing masks in public,” Pepinsky writes in a blog post summarizing their findings. “Mask-wearing levels are consistently lower across the board in states that voted strongly for Trump.” Why would Republicans treat masks as a partisan issue? A series of tweets from R.R. Reno, the editor of the conservative religious magazine First Things, is clarifying: In a diatribe that went viral on Tuesday night for all the wrong reasons, Reno praised Trump for failing to wear a mask when meeting a group of World War II veterans — and went on to describe the very idea of masks as a kind of surrender: By the way, the WWII vets did not wear masks. They're men, not cowards. Masks=enforced cowardice. — R.R. Reno (@rr_reno) May 13, 2020 Just to reinforce. Talked to my son in Seattle. The mask culture if fear driven. Masks+cowardice. It's a regime dominate by fear of infection and fear of causing of infection. Both are species of cowardice. — R.R. Reno (@rr_reno) May 13, 2020 Look, let's face it. There are those who are terrified, and those who are not. Where do you stand? Terror or a more reasonable position? Will you visit our mother? If so, the mask is a PC gesture. If not, you are a moral monster. — R.R. Reno (@rr_reno) May 13, 2020 Reno has written a lot of goofy stuff during the coronavirus epidemic. But what he’s saying here tells us a lot about the right’s approach to coronavirus more broadly. The first thing that leaps out is that the anti-mask crusade reflects a particular vision of masculinity. Reno’s reframing of an obvious public health measure as a kind of cowardice, something tough World War II veterans would never do, is a thinly veiled way of calling protective masks unmanly. As my colleague Anna North argues, this strain of anxious masculinity is a consistent theme in anti-mask arguments on the right. The second is the argument that mask-wearing is a form of “political correctness.” Reno’s reasoning is incoherent — if you’re willing to visit your mother, presumably you should take mask-wearing even more seriously — but it illustrates the category of thinking he’s relying on here. The question in his mind is not “does wearing a mask contribute to public health,” but rather “what does wearing a mask say about where I stand in the culture war.” He sees the issue not through the lens of substance, but of symbolism. When you look at the broader Republican response to masks through the lens of Reno’s thinking, it starts to make a lot more sense. This is a political movement that has been built to wage a culture war; it has no greater objective than owning the libs. And the best way to own them is to defeat them in combat over identity: gender, race, sexuality, and the like. The war on masks is a way of taking a public health crisis — a situation that demands political unity and best practices in governance — and reshaping it into a culture war competition. The question is not “are we doing a good job handling this” so much as “whose team do you want to be on, the namby-pamby liberals or the strong fearless conservatives?” It is difficult for members of the modern organized conservative movement to see political issues outside the lenses of partisanship and the culture wars. At a time when unity on public health matters is paramount, on issues ranging from masks to testing to the timing of reopening, this is dangerous. __________________________________________________________________ Support Vox's explanatory journalism Every day at Vox, we aim to answer your most important questions and provide you, and our audience around the world, with information that empowers you through understanding. Vox’s work is reaching more people than ever, but our distinctive brand of explanatory journalism takes resources. Your financial contribution will not constitute a donation, but it will enable our staff to continue to offer free articles, videos, and podcasts to all who need them. Please consider making a contribution to Vox today, from as little as $3. Next Up In Politics & Policy Most Read 1. Still going to the grocery store? With new virus variants spreading, it’s probably time to stop. Health experts say you should avoid optional trips whenever you can. You probably need a better mask, too. 2. Terrible financial advice is going viral on TikTok TikTok is full of dubious personal finance myths. Here are 10 of them, and why you should be wary. 3. The paradox of online “body positivity” Is this the beginning of a mainstream fat acceptance movement? Or will it be buried by the algorithms? 4. Sen. Lindsey Graham calls for Senate to reject impeachment trial for “national healing” Graham is questioning the legitimacy of a trial after Trump leaves office. But Dems and some scholars disagree. 5. As Trump prepares for final presidential pardons, will he attempt to pardon himself? Trump is reportedly planning to make more than 100 pardons before leaving office. Sign up for the newsletter Future Perfect Get our newsletter in your inbox twice a week. Email (required) ____________________ By signing up, you agree to our Privacy Notice and European users agree to the data transfer policy. For more newsletters, check out our newsletters page. (BUTTON) Subscribe The Latest Heightened security measures are being put in place around the U.S. Capitol Building. Heightened security measures are being put in place around the U.S. Capitol Building. What we know about Biden’s inauguration plans By Nicole Narea Why the FBI is vetting the National Guard ahead of the inauguration By Fabiola Cineas Joe Biden bows his head in prayer in front of a stained glass window. Joe Biden bows his head in prayer in front of a stained glass window. What the clergy praying at Biden’s inauguration signal about his priorities By Alissa Wilkinson Trump, in a long unbuttoned black dress coat, wind pulling at his bright red tie, smiles and raises his right arm, giving a thumbs up. Behind him loom the massive black bars of the border wall, dark against a grey sky. Trump, in a long unbuttoned black dress coat, wind pulling at his bright red tie, smiles and raises his right arm, giving a thumbs up. Behind him loom the massive black bars of the border wall, dark against a grey sky. As Trump prepares for final presidential pardons, will he attempt to pardon himself? By Anya van Wagtendonk Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. looks at the camera, with points of light obscuring parts of his face. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. looks at the camera, with points of light obscuring parts of his face. How the FBI’s surveillance of Martin Luther King Jr. was bolstered by Hollywood By Alissa Wilkinson The cover of Detransition, Baby features many different faces abstractly collaged together. The cover of Detransition, Baby features many different faces abstractly collaged together. One Good Thing: Detransition, Baby lays bare the innermost thoughts of trans women By Emily VanDerWerff Chorus * Terms of Use * Privacy Notice * Cookie Policy * Do Not Sell My Personal Info * Licensing FAQ * Accessibility * Platform Status * Contact * Send Us a Tip * Masthead * About Us * Editorial Ethics and Guidelines Vox Media Vox Media logo. Advertise with us Jobs @ Vox Media © 2021 Vox Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved Share this story * Twitter * Facebook