Skip to main content (BUTTON) Menu Times Higher Education (THE) * * * * Professional + News + Opinion + Reader Comments + Books + Features + Awards + Digital Editions * Jobs + Find a job + Jobs by email + Search recruiters + Careers advice * Summits * Rankings + World University Rankings + US College rankings + Japan University Rankings + By subject + News + About * Student + Best universities + Where to study + News + Advice + Blogs + Find a University + Subjects * About Us * * * (BUTTON) × Please log in * * * * or E-mail or username * ____________________________________________________________ Password * ____________________________________________________________ (Log in) Log in Not a member yet? Join us for FREE Forgotten Password? (BUTTON) ×Close Register now for free * * * * or Choose your profile * [You are a ...___________] Email * ____________________________________________________________ A valid e-mail address. All e-mails from the system will be sent to this address. The e-mail address is not made public and will only be used if you wish to receive a new password or wish to receive certain news or notifications by e-mail. Password ____________________________________________________________ Username * _______________________________________________________________________ Newsletters [X] Higher education updates from the THE editorial team [X] World University Rankings news [ ] If you do not wish to be contacted about offers, products or services from THE/TES Global then please check this box (Join us) Join us By registering, you agree to our cookie policy and terms and conditions. Already have a THE account? Log in now * Login * Register * Subscribe * Share on twitter * Share on facebook * Share on google * Share on whatsapp ____________________________________________________________ (GO) GO UK leads Europe in the fight against plagiarism Some continental efforts to ensure integrity are ‘primitive’, study finds October 10, 2013 * Share on twitter * Share on facebook * Share on linkedin * Share on whatsapp * Share on mail * By Elizabeth Gibney [silhouette_of_man_at_computer.jpg?itok=7a6OdGud] Source: Alamy Copy that?: systems to promote good practice are patchy across the EU The UK has the most mature system in Europe for promoting academic integrity among students, a study has found. The analysis looked at factors such as universities’ use of plagiarism software, consistency of sanctions, transparency, training, efficacy of prevention policies and efforts to address the issue at a national level. “There’s no doubt that in the UK we’re a lot more advanced than most countries, in most aspects,” said Irene Glendinning, academic manager for student experience at Coventry University and principal investigator on the Impact of Policies for Plagiarism in Higher Education across Europe project. The study - based on a voluntary and anonymous survey of about 5,000 students, teachers and senior managers, and on interviews with representatives of national higher education bodies - found Austria and Sweden to have the next most advanced systems, followed by the Republic of Ireland and Malta. Bulgaria and Spain were tied in last place among European Union nations, both performing poorly on all criteria except their knowledge and understanding of academic integrity. Germany, Italy and France were all ranked in the lower half of the table. Ms Glendinning said that unlike in the UK, where efforts to prevent and detect plagiarism have been growing since 2001, in Spain students reported that tools to detect plagiarism were rarely used, and only one-third said there were policies for dealing with the problem. In other countries such as France, some respondents suggested that academic integrity was not an issue that needed to be addressed at the undergraduate stage, she added. It was surprising how “primitive” systems for dealing with academic integrity were in countries such as Germany and Finland, which had otherwise excellent reputations for education, Ms Glendinning said. “We found some pockets of good practice there, but most people really are in the Dark Ages in comparison with what’s going on in the UK and anglophone countries such as Australia and the US,” she said. Another surprising finding was that across Europe, students were more likely than teachers to believe that policies and sanctions were applied fairly and consistently, Ms Glendinning added. She cautioned that some scores for low-performing countries were based on very few respondents, despite significant efforts at recruitment. But she added that this itself could indicate that the situation is even worse than the data suggest. “We suspect the reason we’re not getting any engagement in those countries is because this is not seen as an issue there,” she said. Ms Glendinning also acknowledged that the survey looked at policies and their implementation rather than the prevalence of plagiarism because, she said, such data simply did not exist. “There’s no doubt that there’s a lot of plagiarism around … but there are no statistics anywhere,” she said. Consistent recording would mean “we can have a handle on whether what we’re doing is actually having an effect”. The full results of the project, including country breakdowns, will be published by the end of November. These will include recommendations, drawn up with project partners in Lithuania, the Czech Republic, Poland and Cyprus. Among suggestions for the UK will be that the Quality Assurance Agency should, as part of existing audits, require institutions to explain their plagiarism policies and demonstrate their effectiveness and consistency. elizabeth.gibney@tsleducation.com You've reached your article limit. Register to continue Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus: * Sign up for the editor's highlights * Receive World University Rankings news first * Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches * Participate in reader discussions and post comments Register Subscribe Or subscribe for unlimited access to: * Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews * Digital editions * Digital access to THE’s university and college rankings analysis * Unrestricted access to the UK and global edition of the THE app on IOS, Android and Kindle Fire [image-ipad.png] Subscribe Already registered or a current subscriber? Sign in now Read more about Read more about: Students Have your say Log in or register to post comments Featured Jobs [] PhD Fellowship within Artificial Intelligence for Exposed Aquaculture Operations Norwegian University Of Science & Technology -ntnu [] Senior Course Tutor in English for Academic Purposes University Of Nottingham Ningbo China [] Assistant Professor in Psychology Qatar University [] Assistant Professor in Mechatronics Queens University [] Lecturer, Finance Rmit Vietnam See all jobs Most Viewed Most beautiful universities in the UK The 10 most beautiful universities in the UK January 1, 2018 Map of Europe/Best universities in Europe Best universities in Europe September 14, 2017 University of Oxford, University Church of St Mary the Virgin Best universities in the UK September 5, 2017 The University of Melbourne - the top ranked institution in Australia Best universities in Australia September 5, 2017 Best universities in Canada 2018 Best universities in Canada September 5, 2017 Looking for the next step in your career? Job title, keywords or company name ____________________________________________________________ Location ____________________________________________________________ (Search Jobs) Search Jobs Most Commented Smog in China How can scholars tackle the rise of Chinese censorship in... There is growing concern that China is trying to silence its critics in the West, with academic publishers a particular target. Tao Zhang considers the consequences for scholarly freedom – and what can be done to tackle such restrictions Machiavelli jumping over a horse A Machiavellian guide to getting ahead in academia Rogier Creemers advises early career academics to be ruthless and put themselves first to move up the ladder Stephen Bax Stephen Bax, 1960-2017 Academic whose research interests were shaped by an African childhood remembered Team of researchers with microscopes REF cycles ‘force academics to rush out poorer quality... Study finds 35 per cent increase in publications ahead of submission deadline, but 12 per cent decline in citations Woman behind man playing bagpipes Women ‘more likely to be pressured to add authors’ to... Junior researchers also more likely to feel they have to give credit to colleagues who made minimal contributions Tweets by @timeshighered You might also like cuts Demand for cuts deals death blow to Australia’s demand-driven system January 4, 2018 Heads with lightbulb brains (illustration) There is no such thing as ‘critical thinking’ January 4, 2018 Man and woman peer out from behind bunches of bananas New year predictions: what does 2018 have in store for universities? January 4, 2018 [istock-667434682.jpg?itok=s0tygauv] Toby Young OfS appointment epitomises how the privileged seldom fail January 3, 2018 * Contact Us * About Us * Write for the THE * Terms & Conditions * Cookie Policy Times Higher Education subscriptions Subscribe If you like what you're reading online, why not take advantage of our subscription and get unlimited access to all of Times Higher Education's content? You'll get full access to our website, print and digital editions, and the Times Higher Education app for iOS, Android and Kindle Fire devices. Subscribe [?pid=10648&sg=DeUr-8da6f5e5]