[tr?id=901398199913408&ev=PageView&noscript=1] IFRAME: //www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-NFRQLH * Subscriptions from £4.49 » * User * * Log in ____________________ ____________________ (BUTTON) Log In Forgotten Password? Need an account? * Need help? + FAQ + Contact us * Notices * Horoscopes * Today's paper Irishnews Logo Logo * Share on facebook * Share on twitter * Share via email * * * Logo * * News * Sport * Business * Life * Arts * Notices * Opinion * Puzzles * Photos * ____________________ (BUTTON) ____________________ (BUTTON) Search (BUTTON) Sections * Northern Ireland news * UK News * Republic of Ireland news * World news * Political news * Education news * Healthcare news * Nama * Refugee Crisis Stories Two men arrested after attempted murder in Belfast Northern Ireland news Two men arrested after attempted murder in Belfast PSNI 'hasn't acted on Lisa Dorrian burial information' News PSNI 'hasn't acted on Lisa Dorrian burial information' DUP lack necessary 'element of skill' for Guinness records honour News DUP lack necessary 'element of skill' for Guinness records honour Rembrandt masterpiece on display at Ulster Museum News Rembrandt masterpiece on display at Ulster Museum Sections * GAA Football * GAA Fixtures * Club Call * Hurling and camogie * Soccer * Boxing * Rugby * Golf * Athletics * Off The Fence * Racing * Opinion * Other Sports Stories Farrell shines for Saracens in commanding win over Ulster Rugby Union Farrell shines for Saracens in commanding win over Ulster John Terry rescues point for Chelsea in six-goal thriller Football/Soccer John Terry rescues point for Chelsea in six-goal thriller Aguero strikes twice as Man City ease to win over Crystal Palace Football/Soccer Aguero strikes twice as Man City ease to win over Crystal Palace McKenna Cup Liveblog: Tyrone v Fermanagh - semi-final GAA Football McKenna Cup Liveblog: Tyrone v Fermanagh - semi-final Sections * July Budget * Business news * Economics * Personal finance * Business columnists * Business Insight * Markets Stories BT's £12.5bn takeover of EE cleared by competition watchdog Business BT's £12.5bn takeover of EE cleared by competition watchdog ‘The Jungle' named ‘thrilling' at Outdoor NI Awards Business ‘The Jungle' named ‘thrilling' at Outdoor NI Awards Northern Ireland's top buildings come under the spotlight Business Northern Ireland's top buildings come under the spotlight Drinks Inc planning 12 redundancies says Siptu union Business Drinks Inc planning 12 redundancies says Siptu union Sections * Family and Parenting * Property * Holidays & Travel * Fashion & Beauty * Motors/drive * Food & drink * Celebrity * Gardening * Environment * Health * Faith Matters * TV and Radio Stories Eating Out: The goodness is in the food at Goodness Rocks Life Eating Out: The goodness is in the food at Goodness Rocks TV Review: Cold War spy thriller Deutschland 83 Life TV Review: Cold War spy thriller Deutschland 83 Mais non! The doggy bag will never catch on in Paris Life Mais non! The doggy bag will never catch on in Paris Cycling trip a great way to see Vietnam and Cambodia Life Cycling trip a great way to see Vietnam and Cambodia Sections * Film * Music * Books * Pipe Band Digest * Stage * Irish language Stories Tá bliain chorraitheach chinniúnach roimh Fhorbairt Feirste Irish language Tá bliain chorraitheach chinniúnach roimh Fhorbairt Feirste Raquel Pelzel has just the recipe for taking toast to the next level Arts Raquel Pelzel has just the recipe for taking toast to the next level Cult Movie: Day Of The Outlaw as much noir as Western Film Cult Movie: Day Of The Outlaw as much noir as Western Oscars 2016 - Ten great Irish Oscar moments Film Oscars 2016 - Ten great Irish Oscar moments Sections * Family Notices * Lives Remembered Stories Cocktail king Joe Gilmore, Belfast's barman to the stars Lives Remembered Cocktail king Joe Gilmore, Belfast's barman to the stars Lord Erne of Crom Castle was popular figure in Fermanagh Lives Remembered Lord Erne of Crom Castle was popular figure in Fermanagh ‘My brother loved to entertain with his music' Lives Remembered ‘My brother loved to entertain with his music' Falls Road artist was grand old man of sci-fi's golden age Notices Falls Road artist was grand old man of sci-fi's golden age Sections * Letters to the Editor * Leading article * Cartoons * Columnists Stories Arlene Foster right on Easter Rising and the Somme Columnists Arlene Foster right on Easter Rising and the Somme Election-mode Arlene Foster in old-school reshuffle Columnists Election-mode Arlene Foster in old-school reshuffle Cologne attacks highlight push to extremes Columnists Cologne attacks highlight push to extremes Time for a genuine Fresh Start at Stormont Leading article Time for a genuine Fresh Start at Stormont Sections * Photo of the Day * Graduation pictures * Picture galleries * Video diaries Stories Belfast Zoo animals enjoy the snow Picture Galleries Belfast Zoo animals enjoy the snow New Year celebrations from around the world Picture Galleries New Year celebrations from around the world Storm Frank lashes Ireland Picture Galleries Storm Frank lashes Ireland Harland & Wolff Welders win the Steel & Sons Cup 2015 Picture Galleries Harland & Wolff Welders win the Steel & Sons Cup 2015 (BUTTON) Irishnews Logo (BUTTON) * Login User / Logout * Subscriptions * Home * Today's paper * News Sections + Back + Northern Ireland news + UK News + Republic of Ireland news + World news + Political news + Education news + Healthcare news + Nama + Refugee Crisis * Sport Sections + Back + GAA Football + GAA Fixtures + Club Call + Hurling and camogie + Soccer + Boxing + Rugby + Golf + Athletics + Off The Fence + Racing + Opinion + Other Sports * Business Sections + Back + July Budget + Business news + Economics + Personal finance + Business columnists + Business Insight + Markets * Life Sections + Back + Family and Parenting + Property + Holidays & Travel + Fashion & Beauty + Motors/drive + Food & drink + Celebrity + Gardening + Environment + Health + Faith Matters + TV and Radio * Arts Sections + Back + Film + Music + Books + Pipe Band Digest + Stage + Irish language * Notices Sections + Back + Family Notices + Lives Remembered * Opinion Sections + Back + Letters to the Editor + Leading article + Cartoons + Columnists * Puzzles * Photos Sections + Back + Photo of the Day + Graduation pictures + Picture galleries + Video diaries * Our journalists * Horoscopes ____________________ (BUTTON) Search (BUTTON) Opinion Atrocity obliges us to ask bigger questions Atrocity obliges us to ask bigger questions * * * * * Jarlath Kearney 14 January, 2015 00:00 LAST week's events in Paris were about power. The intentional killing of unarmed civilians is always about power: unaccountable, amoral, fascistic power. There are no moral distinctions between intentionally murdering creative cartoonists in Paris and intentionally blowing up civilian hospitals in Gaza. Self-titled 'religious' terrorists and self-righteous state terrorists may sit at different levels on the spectrum of unaccountable power. But make no mistake: they both occupy the same fascist spectrum. And they both cynically abuse virtuous values to justify unaccountable actions in pursuit of unchallengeable power. That's partly why mainstream political and media discourse rapidly (and lazily) framed last week's events within the narrow safety of two neatly related narratives. The first narrative is that the murderous outrage against Charlie Hebdo was about attacking 'freedom of the press' - a code for 'western' democratic values. That's absolutely true. The actual attack was about silencing intellectual satire with physical violence. It was a hammer of obtuse brutality crushing a voice of creative democracy. The second narrative is that last week's events are another example of Islamic (and anti-Semitic) terrorism striking the heart of 'our' western democracies with ferocious religious fanaticism. That's also true. There is undoubtedly an extreme form of non-state international terrorism claiming flawed allegiance to Islamic teaching. It is anathema to the greatness and goodness of most followers of Islam - lots of whom live in Ireland. But neither of those twin narratives fully explains the past week in Paris. It wasn't just about 'Islamic terrorist fanatics attacking wholesome western democracy'. And once you reach that conclusion; once you rationally delve deeper into such complex events, then you're obliged to start asking much bigger questions. Questioning the mainstream narrative isn't a betrayal of Charlie Hebdo's values. Rather, it's an homage to that vision which has spoken truth to power (however controversially in the past). Dozens of world leaders and diplomats attended Sunday's memorial in Paris: yet how many of their states have ever murderously attacked oppositional media offices or journalists? In their 'resource wars'? In their colonies? In the Baltics? The Occupied Palestinian Territories? Asia and Africa? Central and Latin America? When was the last time world leaders from those states marched to memoralise any similarly outrageous attack by one of their own 'club' against democratic free speech? Is it not blindingly hypocritical that such state-sponsored terrorism has never inspired a similar consensus of state-led outrage? And is that wilful hypocrisy not - in some sense - exploitable by the very fascists aiming to destroy this generation's efforts at building democracy? These questions (and more) raise uncomfortable answers for anyone framing events in a neatly narrow political/security narrative. They illuminate the global gulf that divides citizens' aspirations for progressive values from the corrupt actions of many powers - state and non-state. France's historic values of liberty, equality, fraternity, collectivism, and social separation of church and state, represent the ideological pantheon of practical republicanism and ethical communism. On Sunday world leaders sought to associate with those historic French values (though not their originating communist roots). And that's why they brazenly descended on Paris. It wasn't about simply facing down violent fascists who, on this occasion, claimed the convenient flag of Islam. It was about selfish symbolism and public positioning - domestic and international. It was about relegitimising an elite consensus of security power under the battered banner of Western neo-liberalism; and cynically seizing on millions of grieving French marching for unity. On Sunday world leaders ignored the inconvenient truth of 20th century European fascism: Mussolini and his Black Shirts in Italy; Hitler and his Brown Shirts in Germany; Franco and his Falangists (and his bishops) in Spain; O'Duffy and his Blueshirts in Ireland. And the inconvenient truth is that the indigenous and enduring challenges against European fascism erupted - not from capitalists or conservatives - but from republican resistance and communist partisans, many of whom were Jews. (The editorial leadership of Charlie Hebdo also came from a communist tradition.) Fascism today remains the amoral exercise of unaccountable power in any guide or circumstance. It abuses whatever flag of convenience fits: 'Islam'; 'Christianity'; 'democracy'; 'security'; 'interventionism'; 'nationalism'. The moral panic from last week's fascist violence will now justify additional infringements of fundamental rights and extra resources for security agencies. Already, 10,000 armed troops on French streets; new privacy invasion laws planned in Britain. A non-state agenda attacking Charlie Hebdo's basic freedom of speech will be cynically exploited by a statist agenda further restricting European freedoms. The irony is palpable. And frightening. Championing accountable democracy means challenging both agendas. j.kearney@irishnews.com * * * * * 14 January, 2015 00:00 Opinion More in Opinion Arlene Foster right on Easter Rising and the Somme Arlene Foster right on Easter Rising and the Somme Election-mode Arlene Foster in old-school reshuffle Election-mode Arlene Foster in old-school reshuffle Cologne attacks highlight push to extremes Cologne attacks highlight push to extremes Most Read * Beware of tax on gifting property to family members * Increase in babies born with 'tongue-tie' * Diagnosing Dyspraxia in your child * Irishman in breastfeeding London Underground row Today's horoscope Horoscope __________________________________________________________________ See a different horoscope: [Select sign] Stay connected Get the day's headlines delivered directly to your inbox ____________________ (BUTTON) Sign Up __________________________________________________________________ Sections News PSNI 'hasn't acted on Lisa Dorrian burial information' 1. PSNI 'hasn't acted on Lisa Dorrian burial information' 2. Families question delays in charging 'Stakeknife' Life Cycling trip a great way to see Vietnam and Cambodia 1. Cycling trip a great way to see Vietnam and Cambodia 2. Cairn Wood: Battle to save amenity from being sold off Business ‘The Jungle' named ‘thrilling' at Outdoor NI Awards 1. ‘The Jungle' named ‘thrilling' at Outdoor NI Awards 2. Northern Ireland's top buildings come under the spotlight Arts Raquel Pelzel has just the recipe for taking toast to the next level 1. Raquel Pelzel has just the recipe for taking toast to the next level 2. Catch up with: The X-Files on Amazon Prime Columnists Arlene Foster right on Easter Rising and the Somme 1. Arlene Foster right on Easter Rising and the Somme 2. Election-mode Arlene Foster in old-school reshuffle Sport Ross McGowan leads Joburg Open at the halfway point 1. Ross McGowan leads Joburg Open at the halfway point 2. Darren Clarke delighted as Europe claim three-point lead Tackle today's puzzles Crosswords From gentle to deadly - Crosswords, Suduko, Codewords, Wordwheels and quizzes Irishnews Logo * Supplements * Send us your story * Contact us * FAQ * About us * Our Journalists * Photo Sales * Careers * WEA * Memoriam Cards * Coaching Days