#work rss Apple RSS The Irish Times - Debate [p?c1=2&c2=8946263&cv=2.0&cj=1] IFRAME: //www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-M9Q373 * Search * Newsletters * Crossword * Notices * My Account * Sign Out * Subscribe * Sign In [adserv|3.0|826.1|4268923|0|225|ADTECH;loc=300;target=_blank;kvtopic=Op inion;cookie=info;] Menu The Irish Times Sun, Jan 17, 2016 ^Sign In Welcome * The Irish Times * News * Sport * Business * Opinion * Life & Style * Culture * More * Video * Podcasts * Executive Jobs * Subscribe * My Account * Sign Out * Sign In * * Opinion * Editorials * Letters * Columnists * An Irishman's Diary * Opinion & Analysis * Martyn Turner By using this website, you consent to our use of cookies. For more information on cookies see our Cookie Policy. (BUTTON) X Internet is an echo chamber for illiberal political correctness Twitterverse is a bubble, removed from most people’s experience Sun, Feb 1, 2015, 07:01 Updated: Sun, Feb 1, 2015, 07:50 Breda O'Brien ‘In Ireland, we have a sad tendency to conform when it comes to political ideas, whether it be the rigid consensus of the 1950s, or the apparently ideologically opposite, but in fact, eerily similar 2015 version.’ Photograph: Getty Images ‘In Ireland, we have a sad tendency to conform when it comes to political ideas, whether it be the rigid consensus of the 1950s, or the apparently ideologically opposite, but in fact, eerily similar 2015 version.’ Photograph: Getty Images Twitter is not the real world. This may seem an obvious statement if you are not on Twitter. It may appear less so if you are. The main requirement to be part of the Twitterverse that deals with Irish current affairs is surgical attachment to a smartphone or computer screen, and a job that allows you to check feeds constantly. This cuts out a significant proportion of the population. It is clear that the self-employed, and those who work in the media and public relations, are going to be online far more often than the average person. So are politicians, or at least, their proxies. It is, in short, a bubble, which considers itself to be vastly important. A Sunday Independent poll last week showed over half of thirtysomethings rarely if ever use Twitter, and only 17 per cent use it every day. One could leave people to their comforting facsimile of the real world, were it not having an impact on media and on general debate. I know radio and television producers who check Twitter obsessively to see the reaction to programmes. They are getting a skewed result, but I suspect they don’t fully realise it. Meanwhile, they are alienating their core audience. On Twitter, very unpleasant people have thousands of followers. So do intelligent, courteous people. But which group has more influence? The echo chamber gets very loud, as people get “called out” for thought crimes. You never know when a tsunami of abuse will be unleashed. Unsurprisingly, the victims’ response is usually shock and withdrawal. Of course, it is not just Twitter. The internet has allowed a culture of blame and shame that is most notable for its irony deficit. So much for free speech For example, not so long ago, people were rightly shocked at the vicious murders in the Charlie Hebdo offices. The event triggered huge debate on free speech. But toleration of free speech is very selective. Take Omar Mahmood, a Muslim student at the University of Michigan, who wrote a gentle satire on political correctness, Do the Left Thing, where he described the “violence” done daily to him as a left-handyd (sic) person in a world of right-handedness. (The “y” in handyd is a reference to womyn’s studies, for those who defy the patriarchy by refusing to engage in patriarchal spelling.) It should have ended there. Instead, Mahmood’s apartment door was vandalised by outraged students, who found his satire “triggering”. Subsequently, he was fired from his job as a columnist with a student paper because it was said his column had created an environment in which the staff felt threatened. Mahmood’s case was highlighted by Jonathan Chait in a piece in the New York magazine. Chait is a self-described liberal hawk who was very supportive of President Obama’s election. His thesis is that a suffocating political correctness is destroying the possibility of civilised debate. Some of the examples he gives make Mahmood’s satire seem anodyne. For example, “UCLA students staged a sit-in to protest microaggressions such as when a professor corrected a student’s decision to spell the word indigenous with an uppercase I.” Capital punishment Apparently, such grammatical choices reflect ideologies. Oppression by denial of the right to use capital letters – you simply could not make it up. Microaggressions, by the way, are small slights that seem insignificant in themselves, but add up to oppressive actions when people are exposed to them every day. When the Twitterverse speaks about microaggressions, it is a politically correct version of “error has no rights”, a phrase attributed to Pope Pius IX, who did not actually use the precise phrase in his (in)famous 1864 Syllabus of Errors. Pius IX had the excuse of writing at a time when nuns and priests were being driven from their religious orders, their property confiscated and bishops arrested or exiled for protesting. There are real injustices in our world too but, ironically, the “error has no rights” attitude which now suffuses the supposed liberal left often damages the very causes they seek to support. Last November, WomenCam, the Women’s Campaign succeeded in getting both Tim Stanley, who is pro-life, and Brendan O’Neill, who is pro-choice, banned from debating in Oxford. They claimed that “it is absurd to think we should be listening to two cisgender men debate about what people with uteruses should be doing with their bodies”. In Ireland, we have a sad tendency to conform: to the rigid consensus of the 1950s, or the apparently ideologically opposite, but in fact, eerily similar 2015 version. Suffocating illiberalism, thinly disguised this time as progressivism, is alive and well. Just ask anyone who has been caught in a Twitterstorm. Subscribe. More from The Irish Times * Opinion “The takeaway message from its negative poster this week might be that it has ceded control of the narrative to Fine Gael.” Photograph: Eric Luke / The Irish Times Fianna Fáil is changing but not quickly enough * Opinion Soldiers attend Mise Eire. George Morrison’s film showed over twenty years of Irish history, from the 1890s to 1918, through existing archive material. Its soundtrack, an orchestral score by Sean O’Riada, became hugely popular Anne Harris: O’Riada’s epic clash of cymbals became a clash of symbols * Opinion The General Post Office from Abbey St after the 1916 Easter Rising: Royal Irish Academy JT Westropp RIA Opinion: Did the 1916 Rising meet the requirements for a ‘just war’? * Opinion Breda O’Brien: Ultrasound is the biggest enemy of abortion on demand ADVERTISEMENT [adserv|3.0|826.1|4268925|0|170|ADTECH;loc=300;target=_blank;kvtopic=Op inion;cookie=info;] ADVERTISEMENT The Irish Times Logo Sign In Email Address ____________________ Password ____________________ [ ] I agree to the Terms & Conditions, Community Standards and Privacy Policy (BUTTON) Sign In Don't have an account? Sign Up Forgot Password? The Irish Times Logo Sign Up First Name ____________________ Surname ____________________ Screen Name ____________________ The name that will appear beside your comments. Email Address ____________________ Confirm Email Address ____________________ Password ____________________ Confirm Password ____________________ [ ] I agree to the Terms & Conditions, Community Standards and Privacy Policy [ ] I would also like to receive occasional update emails from The Irish Times (BUTTON) Create Account Have an account? Sign In The Irish Times Logo Forgot Password? Please enter your email address so we can send you a link to reset your password. Email Address ____________________ (BUTTON) Submit Sign In or Sign Up The Irish Times Logo Thank you You should receive instructions for resetting your password. When you have reset your password, you can Sign In. The Irish Times Logo Hello, . Please choose a screen name. This name will appear beside any comments you post. Your screen name should follow the standards set out in our community standards. Screen Name ____________________ (BUTTON) Confirm The Irish Times Logo Thank you for registering. Please check your email to verify your account. (BUTTON) Sign In (BUTTON) Close Your Comments Sign In Sign Out We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Standards. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or by filling out this form. New comments are only accepted for 3 days from the date of publication. Editorials Guarding the guardians Garda Ombudsman accesses journalists’ phone records The silent victims of austerity Children’s rights: Ireland appears before UN Committee on the Rights of the Child Our Columnists Breda O'Brien Breda O'Brien - Breda O’Brien: Ultrasound is the biggest enemy of abortion on demand Cliff Taylor Cliff Taylor - Election 2016: Get ready to be hit by a digital deluge Paul Gillespie Paul Gillespie - Worldview: Ireland should recognise Palestine if peace talks fail Donald Clarke Donald Clarke - Chief Film Correspondent Donald Clarke: Irish Oscar nods were due to great expectations ADVERTISEMENT [adserv|3.0|826.1|4268924|0|170|ADTECH;loc=300;target=_blank;kvtopic=Op inion;cookie=info;] Letters Crisis in emergency departments French Jews and wearing the kippa Mathematics at third level Women’s rights here and abroad Protecting children online National anthem and copyright law Walking routes and public health Global factors and the economy Investing in rural Ireland Oscar bravo Question Time Question Time: What can be done to address the shortage of Catholic priests? 2:34 Question Time: What can be done to address the shortage of Catholic priests? Question Time: Will Leo Varadkar’s latest plans resolve the hospital waiting list crisis? 1:48 Question Time: Will Leo Varadkar’s latest plans resolve the hospital waiting list crisis? Question Time: Will the Coalition voting pact help to boost Labour’s fortunes? 1:31 Question Time: Will the Coalition voting pact help to boost Labour’s fortunes? Most Read 1 Television: A sugar-crash course in how we are poisoning ourselves 2 Conservative Germany is ‘mad as hell’ over Merkel’s policies 3 Gardaí say remains those of man who died in recent days 4 Bhutan: the price of paradise 5 Isis ‘kills 300 people’ in Deir al-Zor, Syrian government says Never miss a story. SUBSCRIBE Subscribe About Us Policy & Terms Subscribe * Subscription Bundles * Gift Subscriptions * Home Delivery Irish Times Products & Services * ePaper * eBooks * Crosswords * Newspaper Archive * Dating * Ancestors * Email Alerts & Newsletters * Article Archive * Executive Jobs * Page Sales * Photo Sales About Us * Advertise * Contact Us * The Irish Times Trust * Careers Download on the App Store Download on Google Play * Our Partners * Rewarding Times * MyHome.ie * Irish Racing * Entertainment.ie * Top 1000 * MyAntiques.ie * The Gloss * Irish Times Training * Terms & Conditions * Privacy Policy * Cookie Information * Community Standards * Copyright * FAQs © 2015 THE IRISH TIMES For the best site experience please enable JavaScript in your browser settings Sign In ____________________ ____________________ (BUTTON) Sign In Forgot Password? Don't have an account? Subscribe * Subscriber quick links * Newspaper Archive * Crossword Club * IT Sunday * eBooks * Subscriber Benefits * My Account * Sign Out SUBSCRIBE ____________________ (BUTTON) Sun 17/1/2016 * News + Election 2016 + Ireland + World + Politics + Crime & Law + Social Affairs + Health + Education * Sport + Rugby + Soccer + Gaelic Games + Golf + Racing + Other Sports + Women in Sport + Comment * Business + The Economy + Your Money + Companies + Technology + Work + Commercial Property + Comment * Opinion + Editorials + Letters + Columnists + An Irishman's Diary + Opinion & Analysis + Martyn Turner * Life & Style + Food & Drink + Homes & Property + Health & Family + People + Travel + Motors + Fashion * Culture + Books + Film + Music + Stage + Art & Design + TV, Radio, Web + Treibh * More + You are what you read + eBooks + Offers + Jobs + Family Notices + Dating + Competitions * Video + Film Show + New to the Parish + Give Me Five + Feast * Podcasts + Inside Politics + World View + Second Captains + Business + Róisín Meets + Off Topic + The Women's Podcast * Executive Jobs * Crosswords * Newsletters * Notices ____________________ (BUTTON) ____________________ ____________________ Forgot Password? (BUTTON) Sign In Invalid email or password. Subscriber quick links * Newspaper Archive * Crossword Club * ePaper desktop app * IT Sunday * eBooks * Subscriber Benefits * My Account