#work rss Apple RSS The Irish Times - Business [p?c1=2&c2=8946263&cv=2.0&cj=1] IFRAME: //www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-M9Q373 * Search * Newsletters * Crossword * Notices * My Account * Sign Out * Subscribe * Sign In [adserv|3.0|826.1|4366792|0|225|ADTECH;loc=300;target=_blank;kvtopic=Te chnology;kvcat=crime,+law+and+justice;kvcompany=Digital+Rights:Facebook ;cookie=info;] Menu The Irish Times Sun, Jan 17, 2016 ^Sign In Welcome * The Irish Times * News * Sport * Business * Opinion * Life & Style * Culture * More * Video * Podcasts * Executive Jobs * Subscribe * My Account * Sign Out * Sign In * * Business * Technology * Tech Tools All Business * The Economy + Small Business + Budget 2016 * Your Money + Personal Finance + Exchange Rates + Markets * Companies + Financial Services + Agribusiness & Food + Energy & Resources + Health & Pharma + Manufacturing + Media & Marketing + Retail & Services + Transport & Tourism * Technology + Tech Tools * Work + Be Your Best * Commercial Property + Construction * Comment + Columnists * Innovation * Specials + Entrepreneur of the Year + AIB Start-up Academy * Podcasts + Business Podcast By using this website, you consent to our use of cookies. For more information on cookies see our Cookie Policy. (BUTTON) X Will verdict of US online freedom of speech case have an effect globally? Anthony Elonis case widely seen as first formal test of online freedom of speech Thu, Jan 8, 2015, 01:45 Karlin Lillington Anthony Elonis repeatedly posted on Facebook about about killing his ex-wife and gunning down kindergarten children. Photograph: Dado Ruvic/Reuters Anthony Elonis repeatedly posted on Facebook about about killing his ex-wife and gunning down kindergarten children. Photograph: Dado Ruvic/Reuters “There’s one way to love you but a thousand ways to kill you. I’m not going to rest until your body is a mess, soaked in blood and dying from all the little cuts.” Is that a spontaneous, angry rap on Facebook, or a menacing and intimidating threat? In a case that could reshape the boundaries of social media commentary, US supreme court justices will give an opinion this year on that Facebook post and others made by Anthony Elonis, a former amusement park employee. In Elonis v United States – widely seen as the first formal test of online freedom of speech in the country that, unlike most of the rest of the world, provides it constitutional protections – justices will consider the point at which a threat made on social media should be deemed credible, rather than a harmless rant or a form of artistic expression. With international attention increasingly focused on threatening language in social media posts, the case has drawn supporters on both sides of the argument. Victims groups say online threats are every bit as fear-inducing as verbal or written threats. Advocates of free speech say allowing Elonis’s conviction to stand will have a chilling effect on online discussion and could threaten artistic works and satirical writing. The background to the case is that, in 2010, Elonis posted repeatedly about killing his ex-wife. He also made comments about finding a school and gunning down kindergarten children, and slitting the throat of a female FBI agent sent to interview him after the posts raised concern. When his wife obtained a protection order against him, he posted: “Fold up your protection from abuse order and put it in your pocket. Is it thick enough to stop a bullet?” The following day, he posted: “That’s it, I’ve had about enough/ I’m checking out and making a name for myself/ Enough elementary schools in a ten mile radius/ to initiate the most heinous school shooting ever imagined/ and hell hath no fury like a crazy man in a kindergarten class.” After the FBI agent visited his home, he posted: “Little agent lady stood so close, took all the strength I had not to turn the bitch ghost. Pull my knife, flick my wrist and slit her throat.” In a federal court in 2011, Elonis was convicted on five counts of interstate communication of illegal threats and sentenced to 44 months in prison. He appealed the case all the way to the Supreme Court. In arguments heard at the start of December, Elonis’s attorney, John Elwood, said that the key issue to consider was not the words, but the context of the posts and whether Elonis actually intended harm. Elwood argues that his client was venting his emotions in a dramatic way. In the past, Elonis had posted rap lyrics on Facebook under a pseudonym.And, said Elwood, Elonis noted on his Facebook page that he was exercising his constitutional right to free speech by airing such opinions. Artists such as Eminem regularly rapped about violent fantasies, Elwood said. This line of defence had supreme court chief justice John Roberts reciting Eminem lyrics – probably a first for the top court in the US. Roberts wanted a government lawyer to explain whether, in his opinion, Eminem could be prosecuted for his song ’97 Bonnie and Clyde, in which the narrator considers drowning his partner. The justices’ questions to the defence at the hearing suggested they will not be inclined toward the argument that online speech is entitled to greater leeway when interpreting what constitutes a threat. The court has in the past determined that the right to freedom of speech does not cover “true threats”, but it has stated these must be differentiated from “sharp attacks” or “political hyperbole”. Elonis’s lawyers wrote in their original petition to the supreme court that “[T]he inherently impersonal nature of online communication makes such messages inherently susceptible to misinterpretation.” Several of the justices indicated that they did not buy the argument that a threatening rant could be dismissed by the claim that “it’s therapeutic or it’s art,” as chief justice Roberts said. And justice Ruth Bader Ginsberg wondered: “How does one prove what’s in somebody else’s mind?” Which way will the case go? Some commentators fear new limits on the right to freedom of speech, or, if the conviction is overturned, an alarming new era in which almost anything will be allowed in online public forums, no matter how intimidating. Others express doubt that much will change if the court allows the conviction to stand. Justices could argue that the specific context of Elonis’s comments, which continued after a protection order was granted to his spouse, sets it apart from the lyrics of a professional, albeit controversial, rap artist. Under such a contextual interpretation, controversial artworks or works of satire would also likely be exempt from being seen as “threats”. Digital activity Solicitor Simon McGarr, of advocacy group Digital Rights Ireland, feels that the latter is likely to be the outcome of a case he says the court clearly took because it felt a principle was at stake. Unlike the Irish Supreme Court, the US top court chooses which cases it will hear, he notes. “In recent decisions, the US supreme court has shown itself to be very aware of the significance of digital activity, as being part of, and not different to, people’s rights in the US under the constitution. What people do online is an extension of the rest of their life,” he says. Perhaps the case – which, importantly, has a specific context in which artistic expression is being used as a defence – was seen by justices as an opportunity to better define the limits of artistic expression, he says. This could give professional artists greater freedom for controversial work. Might the court’s decision in the US affect how online language is interpreted in Ireland? The issue of online harassment “is very much live in Ireland”, McGarr says, with a recent Oireachtas report on the topic, and a consultation paper on the subject from the Law Reform Commission currently open for public comment. McGarr says the US case is unlikely to have a specific Irish effect. First off, contrary to what many Irish people believe, “Ireland has no guarantee of freedom of speech in the way the US has. We have a constitutional ‘freedom of expression’, but this has to be balanced against other elements of the Irish Constitution”. In addition, Irish law currently considers online threats to fall under the category of harassment and, in some contexts, they could be considered an actual assault, as “an assault is defined in terms of making people believe they in imminent danger” and not just an actual physical assault. Under Irish law, a court could demand online threats be taken down from a social media site, and companies with operations here – which includes many global social media and internet companies – tend to comply with such orders. Thus, a case such as Elonis’s would be unlikely to ever come before a top court here. Nevertheless, the US supreme court’s decision will be watched with interest in “the wider public climate”, he says. “If we take it as given that the US is a leading proponent of free speech, you might find that the case will have an effect globally, over time.” * Topics: * Anthony Elonis * John Elwood * John Roberts * Ruth Bader Ginsberg * Simon Mcgarr * Digital Rights * Facebook Subscribe. More from The Irish Times * Economy Michael Noonan: the Minister for Finance has predicted a balanced budget in headline terms in 2017. Photograph: Eric Luke Government to get leeway to cut tax as Brussels eases targets * Economy Euclid Tsakalotos: Dublin was not on the itinerary of the Greek finance minister’s tour of European capitals this week. Photograph: Francois Lenoir/Reuters Cantillon: Greek crisis brings chorus of disapproval * European Cup Leinster’s Sean Cronin celebrates after scoring a try in their clash with Bath in the European Champions Cup. Photo: Billy Stickland/Inpho Fountain of youth comes good for Leinster with fighting victory * Business Kieran Normoyle: ‘By adding heat back to the body we can increase survival times and increase the likelihood of someone being rescued.’ Photograph: Conor McCabe Photography Learning to sew eased the way to winning award for life jacket design ADVERTISEMENT [adserv|3.0|826.1|4268841|0|170|ADTECH;loc=300;target=_blank;kvtopic=Te chnology;kvcat=crime,+law+and+justice;kvcompany=Digital+Rights:Facebook ;cookie=info;] ADVERTISEMENT The Irish Times Logo Sign In Email Address ____________________ Password ____________________ [ ] I agree to the Terms & Conditions, Community Standards and Privacy Policy (BUTTON) Sign In Don't have an account? Sign Up Forgot Password? The Irish Times Logo Sign Up First Name ____________________ Surname ____________________ Screen Name ____________________ The name that will appear beside your comments. Email Address ____________________ Confirm Email Address ____________________ Password ____________________ Confirm Password ____________________ [ ] I agree to the Terms & Conditions, Community Standards and Privacy Policy [ ] I would also like to receive occasional update emails from The Irish Times (BUTTON) Create Account Have an account? Sign In The Irish Times Logo Forgot Password? Please enter your email address so we can send you a link to reset your password. Email Address ____________________ (BUTTON) Submit Sign In or Sign Up The Irish Times Logo Thank you You should receive instructions for resetting your password. When you have reset your password, you can Sign In. The Irish Times Logo Hello, . Please choose a screen name. This name will appear beside any comments you post. Your screen name should follow the standards set out in our community standards. Screen Name ____________________ (BUTTON) Confirm The Irish Times Logo Thank you for registering. Please check your email to verify your account. (BUTTON) Sign In (BUTTON) Close Your Comments Sign In Sign Out We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the Community Standards. We ask that you report content that you in good faith believe violates the above rules by clicking the Flag link next to the offending comment or by filling out this form. New comments are only accepted for 3 days from the date of publication. Latest Business Paddy Power merger with Betfair clears final hurdle 16 Jan Complaint upheld in UK about website Ryanair is suing 16 Jan Bord Gáis Energy and Airtricity compete for Viridian 16 Jan Government to get leeway to cut tax as Brussels eases targets 16 Jan Cantillon: Greek crisis brings chorus of disapproval 16 Jan ADVERTISEMENT [adserv|3.0|826.1|4268838|0|170|ADTECH;loc=300;target=_blank;kvtopic=Te chnology;kvcat=crime,+law+and+justice;kvcompany=Digital+Rights:Facebook ;cookie=info;] Girl Crew now has more than 20,000 members in 43 cities across the world, including Dublin, London, Melbourne and San Francisco. Photograph: Dara Mac Donaill People to watch in 2016 Ciara O'Brien's pick of tech entrepreneurs to watch in 2016 Tech Tools Tech Tools: Edwin the Duck Edwin stars in a range of interactive stories and games on your tablet Tech Tools: BB-8 Force Band €TBA Band translates your gestures into movement instructions for BB-8 Most Read in Business 1 For the Beeb, the death of Queen Elizabeth will be no joke 2 Starting out on your own: nine things NOT to do 3 Complaint upheld in UK about website Ryanair is suing 4 Netflix to block subscribers from using proxy access services 5 Government to get leeway to cut tax as Brussels eases targets Never miss a story. SUBSCRIBE Web Log Web Log: Intel and Lady Gaga team up to stop online harassment Web Log: Twitter co-founder ‘un-pivots’ with Q&A service Web Log: Close your eyes, breathe … and track Web Log: Habitica app makes a game of new year resolutions Web Log: Polling app Wishbone targets teenage market Game Reviews Tearaway Unfolded Big screen debut for Atoi & Co Angry Birds 2: Bigger, badder, birdier? Not quite. Angry Birds 2 | Game Review Sequel may be fun, but in-app purchases means it falls short of the mark Yoshi’s Woolly World | Game Review Beautifully crafted, but is Yoshi’s latest outing style over substance? Twit or Miss | Game Review Roald Dahl’s ‘Twits’ makes its mobile debut E3 2015 News and analysis from the world's premier trade show for computer and video games Business Today Here is your morning briefing on all our top stories from the Business Desk [image.png] Subscribe on iTunes Follow on Soundcloud Listen on Stitcher Business Columns Arthur Beesley Arthur Beesley - Economics Editor Arthur Beesley: Narrative of recovery must be tempered with caution Laura Slattery Laura Slattery - Journalist No Europuddings as Channel 4 dishes up foreign drama Karlin Lillington Karlin Lillington - Technology Journalist Teenagers risk being defined for life by their social media posts Martin Wolf Martin Wolf - Martin Wolf: Market turmoil means we are in for bumpy ride Business Bites Cantillon: Cantillon: Greek crisis brings chorus of disapproval Cantillon: Cantillon: Tesco turns its Christmas figures around Work: Saying No to things you want to do Work: Social media key tool for B2B firms One More Thing: AIB bolsters its executive ranks One More Thing: Celtic Tiger purrs again as Finance Ireland seeks investors Business Videos CES 2016: robot butlers, Michelin star tea and smart fridges 1:15 CES 2016: robot butlers, Michelin star tea and smart fridges CES 2016: Fitbit and Volvo launch wearable tech 0:53 CES 2016: Fitbit and Volvo launch wearable tech Enterprise Ireland celebrate over 21,000 new jobs in 2015 1:00 Enterprise Ireland celebrate over 21,000 new jobs in 2015 Get an email each morning from the Irish Times business desk briefing you on significant business news. Find out what has happened and what is going to happen during the day ahead. Google ID ____________________ Name ____________________ Surname ____________________ Email ____________________ (BUTTON) Sign Up [X] I would also like to receive occasional update emails from The Irish Times Subscribe About Us Policy & Terms Subscribe * Subscription Bundles * Gift Subscriptions * Home Delivery Irish Times Products & Services * ePaper * eBooks * Crosswords * Newspaper Archive * Dating * Ancestors * Email Alerts & Newsletters * Article Archive * Executive Jobs * Page Sales * Photo Sales About Us * Advertise * Contact Us * The Irish Times Trust * Careers Download on the App Store Download on Google Play * Our Partners * Rewarding Times * MyHome.ie * Irish Racing * Entertainment.ie * Top 1000 * MyAntiques.ie * The Gloss * Irish Times Training * Terms & Conditions * Privacy Policy * Cookie Information * Community Standards * Copyright * FAQs © 2015 THE IRISH TIMES For the best site experience please enable JavaScript in your browser settings Sign In ____________________ ____________________ (BUTTON) Sign In Forgot Password? Don't have an account? Subscribe * Subscriber quick links * Newspaper Archive * Crossword Club * IT Sunday * eBooks * Subscriber Benefits * My Account * Sign Out SUBSCRIBE ____________________ (BUTTON) Sun 17/1/2016 * News + Election 2016 + Ireland + World + Politics + Crime & Law + Social Affairs + Health + Education * Sport + Rugby + Soccer + Gaelic Games + Golf + Racing + Other Sports + Women in Sport + Comment * Business + The Economy + Your Money + Companies + Technology + Work + Commercial Property + Comment * Opinion + Editorials + Letters + Columnists + An Irishman's Diary + Opinion & Analysis + Martyn Turner * Life & Style + Food & Drink + Homes & Property + Health & Family + People + Travel + Motors + Fashion * Culture + Books + Film + Music + Stage + Art & Design + TV, Radio, Web + Treibh * More + You are what you read + eBooks + Offers + Jobs + Family Notices + Dating + Competitions * Video + Film Show + New to the Parish + Give Me Five + Feast * Podcasts + Inside Politics + World View + Second Captains + Business + Róisín Meets + Off Topic + The Women's Podcast * Executive Jobs * Crosswords * Newsletters * Notices ____________________ (BUTTON) ____________________ ____________________ Forgot Password? (BUTTON) Sign In Invalid email or password. Subscriber quick links * Newspaper Archive * Crossword Club * ePaper desktop app * IT Sunday * eBooks * Subscriber Benefits * My Account