#alternate alternate New York Post WordPress.com Thanks for contacting us. We've received your submission. Back to Reading * News * Metro * Page Six * Sports * Business * Opinion * Entertainment * Fashion * Living * Media * Tech * Real Estate * Sub Menu 1 + Photos + Video + Covers + Columnists + Horoscopes * Sub Menu 2 + Classifieds + Subscribe * Sign in In The News: hillary clinton iran lamar odom 2016 presidential election new york mets Sections Search ____________________ (search) Sign in / Register New York Post Share this: * Facebook * Twitter * Google * WhatsApp * Email * Copy * William McGurn William McGurn Opinion Share this: * Facebook * Twitter * Google * WhatsApp * Email * Copy * Democrat suing after failed bid wins by uniting diverse groups in court fight By William McGurn * View author archive * Get author RSS feed Name(required) ____________________ Email(required) ____________________ Comment(required) ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ Submit » March 7, 2014 | 12:50am Modal Trigger Democrat suing after failed bid wins by uniting diverse groups in court fight Part of America's tradition: Stephen Colbert, the coiner of "truthiness," in performance. Photo: Getty Images MORE FROM: William McGurn William McGurn A friend in Jesus: New York's new Catholic PAC The Reagan alternative to Obama's Iran deal Snow(den) blind: Libertarians' telling 'hero' The Bush trap: A Republican foreign policy Brian and Barack: Lies, damned lies, and journalism Think of it as Steve Driehaus’s finest public service. You remember Steve: He’s the Democrat who represented Ohio’s 1st Congressional District — until he voted for ObamaCare, that is. During his 2010 bid for re-election, the Susan B. Anthony List accused Driehaus of voting for taxpayer-funded abortion because of his ObamaCare vote. Driehaus responded by filing a criminal complaint under an Ohio law that criminalizes “false statements” against a candidate. Then, after Ohio’s voters gave him the old heave-ho, Driehaus sued the Susan B. Anthony List on the grounds it had deprived him of his “livelihood” as a congressman. The whole mess is headed for the Supreme Court, which will hear arguments April 22. Now, a politician who sues on the grounds his election defeat caused him “injury in connection with his trade or occupation” is likely to be written off as a crank. And there’s no doubting the sorehead factor here. Still, if the Good Book is right that ye shall know them by their fruits, perhaps we ought to be thanking this man. However inadvertently, Steve Driehaus has inspired some incredible achievements. The first is to bring together people who are seldom in the same room, much less on the same side of a Supreme Court argument. When was the last time you saw the American Civil Liberties Union siding with Citizens United (yes, that Citizens United)? And these are just two of the 21 highly diverse organizations that have filed amicus briefs supporting the Susan B. Anthony List’s bid to get Ohio’s law struck down as an outrageous restriction on free speech. But wait: It gets better. Because among these amicus briefs is one written for the libertarian Cato Institute by P.J. O’Rourke, author and one-time editor of National Lampoon. It’s almost worth having this bad law just to get this brief, a masterpiece that underscores the serious contribution satire brings to politics. Cato starts out strong. In the introduction, it includes “Read my lips: no new taxes!” and “I did not have sexual relations with that woman” as evidence that political claims and the mockery they invite (“whether true, mostly true, mostly not true, or entirely fantastic”) are “cornerstones of American democracy.” At issue, says Cato, is “truthiness” — “truths” asserted “from the gut,” often “without regard to evidence or logic.” These include claims that “President Obama was born in Kenya” or that “Democrats are pinko-communist flag-burners who want to tax churches and use the money to fund abortions so they can use the fetal stem cells to create pot-smoking lesbian ATF agents who will steal all the guns and invite the UN to take over America.” Laws like Ohio’s, it points out, “do not replace truthiness, satire, and snark with high-minded ideas and ‘just the facts.’ ” Instead, they chill debate and “turn commonplace jibber-jabber into a protracted legal dispute.” It goes on to question whether anyone, let alone the Ohio Elections Commission, can determine truth: “Many campaign statements cannot easily be categorized as simply ‘true’ or ‘false.’ According to Politifact.com, President Obama’s claim that ‘if you like your health-care plan you can keep it’ was true five years before it was named the ‘Lie of the Year.’ ” In like manner, it dispatches the contention at the heart of the Driehaus argument in a footnote referencing the Supreme Court’s own decision upholding the individual mandate: “Driehaus voted for ObamaCare, which the Susan B. Anthony List said was the equivalent of voting for taxpayer-funded abortion. Amici are unsure how true the allegation is given that the health-care law seems to change daily, but it certainly isn’t as truthy as calling a mandate a tax.” Cato’s argues we don’t need unelected government commissions to call out falsehoods. There are plenty of players willing to do that on their own. “And if this court isn’t yet convinced of this point,” reads the brief, “amici have but two words more on the subject: Anthony Weiner.” All in all, it’s a call for a robust give and take in our political debate. Read the full argument yourself, at the Cato Institute or Susan B. Anthony List sites. And don’t be so hard on Steve Driehaus. In the end, it is precisely because he was such a sore loser that we now see so many welcome developments: libertarians, liberal civil libertarians and conservatives united in common cause, the prospect of a big victory for the First Amendment in our highest court — and a highly entertaining reminder that, as P.J. O’Rourke and the Cato Institute conclude, “criminalizing political speech is no laughing matter.” Share this: * Facebook * Twitter * Google * WhatsApp * Email * Copy * Filed under politics , steve driehaus Share this article: Share this: * Facebook * Twitter * Google * WhatsApp * Email * Copy * Read Next Say goodbye to welfare reform, New York Read Next Say goodbye to welfare reform, New York Most Popular This Week 1 Suspects claim teen was having sex with father before alleged gang rape Suspects claim teen was having sex with father before alleged gang rape 2 The brutal secrets behind 'The Biggest Loser' The brutal secrets behind 'The Biggest Loser' 3 Nursing home boss bought winning Powerball ticket for worker Nursing home boss bought winning Powerball ticket for worker 4 Your penis pics are bush league Your penis pics are bush league 5 Dad was so drunk, he couldn't report daughter's gang rape Dad was so drunk, he couldn't report daughter's gang rape 6 Here's what Sean Penn agreed to do to party with El Chapo Here's what Sean Penn agreed to do to party with El Chapo Share Selection Columnists John Podhoretz Here's what Sean Penn agreed to do to party with El Chapo Rubio's last-minute theatrics make it a three-man GOP race Bob McManus Here's what Sean Penn agreed to do to party with El Chapo The Cuomo budget: pandering, mischief --- and five golden rings Benny Avni Here's what Sean Penn agreed to do to party with El Chapo The only real solution to the endless North Korea crisis SEE ALL COLUMNISTS Editorials [king_abdullah_ii.jpg?quality=100&strip=all&w=260&h=174& #038;crop=1] Inviting foreigners to intervene in US elections The rape of the US Marine Corps: a lunatic drive for 'fairness' Chris Christie's revenge on 'Jersey Shore' Trending Now on NYPost.com 70,731 Democrat suing after failed bid wins by uniting diverse groups in court fight Bill Clinton's pardon of fugitive Marc Rich continues to pay big 43,850 Democrat suing after failed bid wins by uniting diverse groups in court fight Peeved Aaron Rodgers: Coin-flip bungle was a 'debacle' 28,155 Democrat suing after failed bid wins by uniting diverse groups in court fight Awkward, pandering spectacle of Hillary Clinton trying to ‘be real’ Today's Cover Covers for January 17, 2016 Covers for January 17, 2016 Covers for January 16, 2016 Covers for January 16, 2016 Covers for January 15, 2016 Covers for January 15, 2016 Covers for January 14, 2016 Covers for January 14, 2016 Browse covers archive More Stories Now On Page Six Donald Trump’s brother Robert emerges Now On Decider Is 'Making A Murderer' A Bunch Of Lies? Steven Avery's Ex Says Yes Now On IAF 2:49 Martin O’Malley Is The Coolest 2016 Presidential Candidate New York Post * Twitter * Facebook * Google Plus * 2015 Blessing of the Animals * Apps Help & FAQ * Columnists * Community Guidelines * Contacts * Customer Service * Fantasy Football Draft Calculator * Home Delivery * Home Delivery FAQ * Jobs * NYCFC Giveaway Terms * NYCFC Giveaway Thank You * Page Six Fashion Sweeps Terms * pagesixfashionsweeps-thank-you * Privacy * Privacy * Recommended for You * Reset * RSS Feeds * Search * Terms of Use * Terms of Use * Test Page * The Pascalizer * Verify © Copyright 2016 NYP Holdings, Inc. All rights reserved Terms of Use | Privacy * Sections & Features + News + Real Estate + Page Six + Tech + Sports + Media + Metro + Photos + Entertainment + Video + Business + Alexa + Opinion + Covers + Fashion + Horoscopes + Living + Classifieds * Apps, Alerts & More + Email Newsletters + Apps for iOS and Android + RSS Feeds + NYPost Store + Home Delivery o Subscribe o Manage Subscription o Customer Service * Help/Support + Customer Service + Search + Contact Us o Letters to the Editor o Newsroom Contacts o Reprints o Careers * Advertise + Media Kit + Contacts Post Digital Network * * * * © 2016 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved | TERMS OF USE | PRIVACY | YOUR AD CHOICES Powered by WordPress.com VIP IFRAME: //www.googletagmanager.com/ns.html?id=GTM-TWX9Z9 Send to Email Address ____________________ Your Name ____________________ Your Email Address ____________________ _________________________ loading Send Email Cancel Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Email check failed, please try again Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. Copy Share URL: ____________________ Copy Link Sign Up / Sign In Sign In // Sign Up With your existing account from... With your existing account {* loginWidget *} Use an account with your email address Or with a NYPost.com account {* #userInformationForm *} {* traditionalSignIn_emailAddress *} {* traditionalSignIn_password *} {* traditionalSignIn_signInButton *}{* traditionalSignIn_createButton *} {* /userInformationForm *} Sign Up / Sign In Sign In // Sign Up Welcome back, {* welcomeName *} {* loginWidget *} Or use NYPost.com account Sign Up / Sign In Sign In // Sign Up Welcome back Welcome back, {* welcomeName *} {* #userInformationForm *} {* traditionalSignIn_emailAddress *} {* traditionalSignIn_password *} {* traditionalSignIn_signInButton *} {* /userInformationForm *} Use an account with your email address Or use another account Almost Done! Please confirm the information below before signing in. Please confirm the information below. {* #socialRegistrationForm *} {* socialRegistration_emailAddress *} {* socialRegistration_displayName *} {* socialRegistration_ageVerification *} By clicking "Sign In", you confirm that you accept our terms of service and have read and understand privacy policy. {* backButton *} {* socialRegistration_signInButton *} {* /socialRegistrationForm *} Almost Done! {* #registrationForm *} {* traditionalRegistration_emailAddress *} {* traditionalRegistration_password *} {* traditionalRegistration_passwordConfirm *} {* traditionalRegistration_displayName *} {* traditionalRegistration_captcha *} {* traditionalRegistration_ageVerification *} By clicking "Create account", you confirm that you accept our terms of service and have read and understand our privacy policy. {* backButton *} {* createAccountButton *} {* /registrationForm *} Create a new password Forgot Password? Don't worry, it happens. We'll send you a link to create a new password. {* #forgotPasswordForm *} {* traditionalSignIn_emailAddress *} {* backButton *} {* forgotPassword_sendButton *} {* /forgotPasswordForm *} Create a new password Sent! We've sent an email with instructions to create a new password. Your existing password has not been changed. We've sent an email with instructions to create a new password. Close Account Already Exists {* mergeAccounts *} {* backButton *} Sign in to complete account merge {* #tradAuthenticateMergeForm *} {* traditionalSignIn_emailAddress *} {* mergePassword *} {* traditionalSignIn_signInButton *} {* /tradAuthenticateMergeForm *}