#RSS Feed for Crime articles - Telegraph.co.uk [p?c1=2&c2=6035736&cv=2.0&cj=1] Accessibility links * Skip to article * Skip to navigation [telegraph_print_190.gif] Telegraph.co.uk ___________________ Submit Search - enhanced by OpenText Friday 22 January 2016 * Home * Video * News * World * Sport * Finance * Comment * Culture * Travel * Life * Women * Fashion * Luxury * Tech * Cars * Film * TV * Politics * Investigations * Obits * Education * Science * Earth * Weather * Health * Royal * Celebrity * Defence * Scotland Advertisement 1. Home>> 2. News>> 3. UK News>> 4. Crime The politics of surveillance are about politics, not keeping us safe Is Britain really going to become the first major democracy to log every website its citizens visit? Photo: ALAMY By Mike Harris 5:20PM GMT 04 Nov 2015 Comments Comments Every piece of surveillance legislation proposed by government in the last generation has inevitably been "crucial" to stop terrorists, peadophiles and criminal masterminds who haunt the public consciousness. The new fear is that the internet is giving those with malicious intent a new tool to disrupt - or end - the lives of the law-abiding. So nearly every year we see another piece of draconian legislation aimed at taking control of the internet. In 2012, we had the draft Communications Data Bill (or Snooper's Charter), the most draconian piece of surveillance legislation ever proposed in a democracy. In the summer of 2014, the DRIPA Act was shoved through parliament in 48 hours. It was so illiberal our courts have ruled it breaches the law. "We cannot rely on technology to solve complex human problems, we need human intelligence to fight crime" Now, Theresa May strikes a different tone. May now believes in new safeguards to protect our privacy, including judicial authorisation of surveillance requests, a key demand of the "civil liberties lobby" who have gone from being maligned to praised in the House of Commons. Oversight of our intelligence agencies - woefully lacking in the past - will be improved with a strengthened commissioner. Yet, as ever, the devil will be in the detail of this legislation. The government still hasn't weaned itself off collecting our most private data, it's this battle that will determine how we remember this Bill. The Government wants to enhance the bulk collection and interception of data to keep us safe. The truth is that terrorists have known for some time that the internet is a bad way to communicate. Bin Laden's compound had no internet connection, he wrote his emails in advance and his associates used internet cafes to send them. The killer of Lee Rigby, Michael Adebowale, was highly security-conscious - as a parliamentary report put it "MI5 noted that Adebolajo was a "difficult [suspect] to investigate due to his security-consciousness". He would use pay phones rather than smart phones and barely use electronic communications. The fact is, criminals are already on the Dark Net using highly encrypted communications tools far beyond the reach of our government and police, as brilliantly described by Jamie Bartlett. These tools are also used by dissidents in authoritarian states to hide from the state and protect their free speech and their lives. The Investigatory Powers Bill can't stop this. The technology is too complex, evolving too quickly, and is distributed among a network of internet activists who will do anything to protect human rights activists working in dangerous places. Politicians don't understand this. They just don't get that legions of coders are building technologies to make private communications easier and cheaper. So the parliamentary debate felt like shadow boxing. MPs all agreed new powers were needed, but none understood that the powers they will be signing into law will not be particularly effective in tracking terrorists, but will be good at capturing the data of law-abiding citizens. So every Briton's internet history will be logged to prevent crime, but crime bosses and terrorists using the Dark Net can't be traced. The real concern is that this data, alongside the bulk retention of data, will not be used to prosecute serious crimes, but petty misdemeanors. Protesters in breach of the peace, whistleblowers breaking the Official Secrets Act or school catchment area cheats. The police will have the data to drag up minor crimes 12 months ago to prosecute people they wish to lock away. Go ahead, you may say, but as we saw with the outrageous use of the previous RIPA Act by local councils to prosecute people for low level nuisance, the potential for abuse is huge. IFRAME: http://renderer.qmerce.com/interaction/5639d01360dcf0427c48abf2 Campaign groups like Don't Spy On Us called for comprehensive legislation to reform the law, wanted judicial authorisation for surveillance requests, improved oversight, and no return for the "Snooper's Charter". Having won all these concessions, it would be churlish to say the least, to not thank the Home Secretary for listening. There's some good in this Bill - in particular the double-lock to ensure democratically elected politicians and our independent judiciary sign off on all surveillance warrants. Yet, big questions remain. Is the bulk collection of data lawful, will it be effective and does it offer value for money at a time of police cuts? Is Britain really going to become the first major democracy to log every website its citizens visit? Is this legislation going to enable the mass intercept of all our communications and allow the hacking of our personal devices? Parliament said little on this today, and the response from the Labour frontbench was woeful. We cannot rely on technology to solve complex human problems, we need human intelligence to fight crime. In the choice between police and intelligence officers and the bloated surveillance technology pushed by US corporates, the choice should be clear. The best safeguard of our liberty is eternal vigilance, the same is true for our security. Mike Harris is CEO of 89up and advises the Don't Spy On Us campaign IFRAME: http://cf.eip.telegraph.co.uk/breakoutCards/9d5c3344-6bd5-4cb0-b4a3-6d5 c7c396319.html thetelegraphnews Follow @telegraphnews [11783_460x100_fron_3288884a.jpg] Top news galleries Strictly: hottest romances Strictly Come Dancing As Georgia May Foote and Giovanni Pernice announce that they are moving in together, we look at the couples who found time to tango off-screen Comments Sundance Film Festival 2016: the best of the festival in pictures Actor Fisher Stevens with former Police singer Sting at the Sky Ladder: The Art Of Cai Guo-Qiang Sundance Film Festival 2016 in pictures Highlights and red carpet arrivals from America's largest independent film festival, in Park City, Utah Comments Winter around the world A man cleans snow from his car after a heavy snowfall which started the previous night in Odessa, Ukraine. The Telegraph's pick of the best winter photographs from around the northern hemisphere The week in pictures A round-up of our favourite photographs of the week Animal photos of the week A ray joins Sea life London Aquarium Aquarist Rebecca Carter for a quick 'selfie' during the annual January deep clean All creatures great and small in our ever popular animal gallery iOS 9: The best hidden features iOS 9 is now available to download for iPhone and iPad The latest update to iPhone and iPad software, iOS 9.3, has been announced. Here are some of the features you may have missed from the original iOS 9 Michael Caine: His career in pictures Michael Caine in Get Carter Film Alice Vincent looks back at some of Michael Caine's greatest film appearances. Comments Inside the eye Gargoyle gecko (Rhacodactylus auriculatus) In pics: National Geographic magazine's February issue that features an up-close look at the eyes of various species Comments Celebrity Sightings: 22 January Matt Damon, Lewis Hamilton and Zac Efron In pics: Matt Damon, Lewis Hamilton and Zac Efron Frozen lighthouses Lighthouses consumed by ice at Grand Haven Pier in St Joseph, Michigan In pics: Structures lashed by winter storms turn into giant icicles Advertisement How we moderate telegraphuk Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus. blog comments powered by Disqus IFRAME: //www.facebook.com/plugins/likebox.php?href=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook. com%2FTelegraph.co.uk&width&height=62&colorscheme=light&show_faces=fals e&header=true&stream=false&show_border=true Telegraph on Facebook Advertisement Latest Video>> WW2 colour video: US Marines at Iwo Jima Syrian refugees enjoy snow for first time Man survives after being flung into air in crash Nespresso sues rival for using Clooney lookalike A still from the Wilbur Scoville Google Doodle Google Doodle: who was Wilbur Scoville? Jodie Kidd and the BMW i3 Sponsored by BMW An electrifying drive in the BMW i3 Frontpage email sign up Sign up to our Frontpage news email More from The Telegraph IFRAME: http://s.telegraph.co.uk/international/Barnebys/2014/Barnebys_UK_300x55 0.html Advertisement Advertisement More from the web Loading More from the web Loading SPONSORED FEATURES Business Solutions A group of work colleagues has an intense business conversation on the office Briefing 2016: the business year ahead View BMW Watch Jodie Kidd test drive BMW's greenest sports car View Bibby man and woman invoicing The challenge of actually being paid for your work View Telegraph Travel Save up to 38% on our recommended, tried and tested hotels View Back to top * HOME * News * UK News * Politics * Long Reads * Wikileaks * Jobs * World News * Europe * USA * China * Royal Family News * Celebrity news * Dating * Finance * Education * Defence * Weird News * Editor's Choice * Financial Services * Pictures * Video * Matt * Alex * Comment * Blogs * Crossword * Contact us * Privacy and Cookies * Advertising * Fantasy Football * Tickets * Announcements * Reader Prints * * Follow Us * Apps * Epaper * Expat * Promotions * Subscriber * Syndication (c) Copyright of Telegraph Media Group Limited 2016 Terms and Conditions Today's News Archive Style Book Weather Forecast