#RSS Podcasts E-BUSINESS | TECHNOLOGY | CRM | LINUX | ECTNEWS.COM Welcome Guest | Sign In ECommerceTimes.com [240x40-ect.gif] Search ____________________ Privacy * Business + Boardroom + Deals + Service Providers + Tech Law + Wall Street * E-Commerce + Analytics + Entertainment + Marketing + Online Advertising + Piracy + Search * Enterprise IT + Applications + Cloud Computing + Government + Infrastructure * Mobile + BYOD + Carriers + M-Commerce + Mobile Advertising * Security + Consumer Security + Cybercrime + Enterprise Security + Privacy * SMB * Social Media + Social Media Marketing + Social Networks * Trends + Expert Advice + Hot Topics + Opinions + Trailblazers * Reader Services + Account Management + Discussion + News Alerts + Newsletters + Reader Surveys + RSS / XML Headline Feeds + Search ECT News Network + + ECT News Network Map o CRM Buyer Site Map o E-Commerce Times Site Map o LinuxInsider Site Map o TechNewsWorld Site Map * | * Software Buyers Guide January 22, 2016 01:14:55 PM PST E-Commerce Times > Security > Privacy | Next Article in Privacy Surveillance Rights and Wrongs, Part 1: Begging the Questions By Richard Adhikari Jan 3, 2014 5:00 AM PT The NSA's surveillance of Americans' emails, Web searches and phone calls has angered the nation, but lawmakers remain divided on the issue. Bipartisan groups have spoken out against the surveillance and a few have introduced legislation to curb it, but some contend it is essential to protect America from its enemies. Surveillance Rights and Wrongs, Part 1: Begging the Questions Americans are not hesitant about posting the most intimate details of their lives on the Web. In fact, the NSA would probably do better to drop its surveillance and just get the records of suspects from the Internet companies themselves, though those high-tech companies are now fighting it tooth and nail -- at least publicly. Certainly, that approach would save billions of taxpayer dollars. Recent developments seem to point to a shift away from the NSA. Are we going to see it reined in? Will there be stricter curbs on what the agency can do and how it does that? 'Common-Sense Reforms' On Dec. 17, U.S. Federal District Court Judge Richard Leon shook up the debate over the NSA's surveillance activities when he ruled that the agency's collection of telephone metadata is likely a violation of the Fourth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. Then, on Dec. 19, the White House released a scathing review of the NSA's surveillance activities by a task force. On Dec. 20 President Obama indicated he might stop the NSA's collection and storage of Americans' phone records and have phone companies hold the data instead, although he defended the agency, saying he had seen no evidence that it acted inappropriately with the records. Taken together, these events might presage a change in the NSA's surveillance of Americans. "The government should always seek to protect the privacy and civil liberties of its citizens, as well as their safety," Jake Laperruque, a fellow on privacy, surveillance and security at the Center for Democracy and Technology, told the E-Commerce Times. "Ending bulk collection, closing the backdoor search loophole and enacting other common-sense reforms will better safeguard civil liberties without harming the government's ability to protect national security," Laperruque continued. Defending the Snoops President Obama last month reiterated claims that various restrictions, safeguards and audits ensure that the NSA and other intelligence agencies do not spy on Americans. Opponents of the NSA's spying programs might not agree. First, NSA officials have admitted to illegally collecting metadata about Americans' phone calls, including tracking cellphones worldwide. Second, the secretive FISA Court, which grants the NSA warrants for surveillance and is claimed by the Obama administration to be one of the checks on the agency's power, may have been talked up. It cannot investigate issues of noncompliance, its chief judge, U.S. District Judge Reggie B. Walton, told the Washington Post. The NSA's Activities Today The NSA spies on both Americans and our allies; has infected 50,000 networks worldwide with malware; placed secret servers code-named "Quantum" at key places on the Internet backbone as part of its so-called "Turmoil" system; runs programs such as Quantum and Foxacid to hack into people's browsers; runs the PRISM program to collect users' data; uses Google cookies to tap into people's PCs; and tracks 5 billion cellphone locations worldwide every day. Facebook hop distance As Facebook has grown, the number of "hops" separating any two people has decreased dramatically. Americans' communications with people abroad are prime targets, and the NSA has claimed that only people with links to suspects are its targets. However, the agency's "three hops" rule widens its net considerably. Here's how the three hops rule works: The first hop targets a suspect's direct friends and acquaintances -- including those on their social media page. The second targets friends of friends. The third goes for, yes, friends of friends of friends. That could lead to thousands of people being swept up into the NSA's surveillance net. Any two Facebook friends together know practically every one of the social network's approximately 1.3 billion other users, one study found. "With neither public debate nor court authorization, the NSA is automating guilt by association, on a global scale," Rebecca Jeschke, media relations director for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, told the E-Commerce Times. Privacy activists and others opposed to the NSA's surveillance of Americans contend it has broken the law and has breached the Fourth Amendment. Judge Leon's ruling appears to bear them out, although he has stayed it pending appeal by the Obama administration. The Justice Department's response was to state the agency's telephone metadata collection program is constitutional. Police Gone Wild Local law enforcement agencies are also tracking citizens' cellphones. The latest weapon in their arsenal is the "Stingray" -- a device developed for spy agencies that captures cellphone traffic by simulating a cell tower. Sometimes, they ask for a "tower dump" -- all the cellphone traffic recorded during a specific period by a particular cell tower. Tower dumps are widespread, and at least 25 law enforcement agencies own a Stingray, a joint investigation by USA Today, 10 News and Gannett has found. Proudly Protecting Americans? Similarly, the NSA has claimed that its surveillance of Americans' phone calls has helped prevent 50 or so potential terrorist attacks, but it has not provided any proof. In fact, Judge Leon ruled that there is no evidence that surveillance of phone calls -- aimed at providing timely information on possible attacks -- does so. Still, terrorists are turning to mobile phones. For instance, the men who attacked the Taj Mahal Hotel in Mumbai in 2008 used cellphones and VoIP accounts to coordinate their activities. Then there's the Global Islamic Media Front, which has released encryption software for mobile phones running Android and Symbian. Governments have to keep their citizens safe, Avni Rambhia, digital media industry manager for Frost & Sullivan, told the E-Commerce Times. In a time when technology is fast dissolving national boundaries and enabling would-be criminals and terrorists to communicate rapidly and set up attacks at frenetic speed, can anyone definitively state that surveillance is entirely wrong? Above the Law? "I'm not sure if 'has the NSA broken the law?' is the right question to ask," Brian Pascal, a research fellow at UC Hastings College of the Law, told the E-Commerce Times. "To me, the question is, 'how effective has the oversight been?'" The FISA Court has found on multiple occasions that the NSA had misrepresented its activities to the court, and NSA officials have withheld the truth even in congressional hearings, Pascal pointed out. "General Alexander even said that no one within the NSA understood the entirety of the systems," he said. Despite this, the FISA Court has routinely reauthorized the NSA's surveillance, Pascal noted. "This means that, at least in the eyes of the FISC judges, the NSA's activities were 'legal.'" If no one understands the system, has it run amok? And in that case, why is the FISA Court reauthorizing surveillance warrants? Is it time the system was overhauled? The task force whose report was released last month suggests that's the case for both the FISA Court and the NSA. [end-enn.gif] Surveillance Rights and Wrongs, Part 2: No Clear Answers. __________________________________________________________________ [Richard Adhikari.jpg] Richard Adhikari has written about high-tech for leading industry publications since the 1990s and wonders where it's all leading to. Will implanted RFID chips in humans be the Mark of the Beast? Will nanotech solve our coming food crisis? Does Sturgeon's Law still hold true? __________________________________________________________________ [ccc-button.png] Get Permission to License or Reproduce this Article Print Email Reprints More by Richard Adhikari Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Google+ [navicon-stumbleupon_32x32.png] RSS [icon_mostpop_14x14roundcorner.png] Most Popular [icon_newsletter_16x12.png] Newsletters [icon_alert_14x14.png] News Alerts How do you rate YouTube vs. TV content? (*) TV is better -- YouTube's content doesn't compare. ( ) YouTube hands down -- it's original, while TV is stale. ( ) There's no comparison -- it's an apple vs. an orange. ( ) I watch and like plenty of both. ( ) With so many content choices, there's still very little that's good. ( ) I'm not tuned into either -- there are better things to do with my time! (BUTTON) Vote or See Results TechNewsWorld Facebook Opens Sports Stadium Brave Browser Promises to Defend Users' Privacy Chrome Browser to Blaze With Brotli GM Bug Program Gets Mixed Notices Child Laborers Mine for Cobalt Used in Tech Gadgets SpaceX Finds Silver Lining in Failed Sea Landing Ukraine Mounts Investigation of Kiev Airport Cyberattack Reading, Writing and Minecraft? CRM Buyer Cloud Research Demandware Teams With eBay on Omnichannel E-Commerce Solution The Top 20 CRM Blogs of 2015: Part 1 Vendor of the Future FordPass Aims to Engage Customers on Their Terms Taxpayer Advocate Blasts IRS' Planned Customer Service Revamp Loyalty and Engagement Amazon UK Lets Customers Pay in Installments LinuxInsider Snap-Happy Trojan Targets Linux Servers Zero-Day Flaw Puts Millions of Linux Machines, Android Devices at Risk Deepin Takes Linux to New Depths OpenSSH Flaw Could Leak Crypto Keys Dronecode Project Gets More Wind Beneath Its Wings Black Duck Intros Container Scanning Solus Project's Virtues Begin and End With Stability Hack Lets PS4 Run Linux SPONSOR RESOURCES CRM Software Buyer's Guide This free buyer's guide compares the best CRM software systems and allows you to request a price or demo for the system that best fits your needs. Marketers - Fill Your Sales Funnel Instantly [sales-funnel_60x60.jpg] Access millions of IT and business decision makers. Our full-service global marketing program delivers sales-ready leads. Learn more. E-Commerce Times Headlines E-Commerce Times Consumer Advocates Push FCC on Broadband Privacy Rules Apple Stats Reflect Slow Slog Toward Diversification ESPN Boss Sees Significant Role for Sling TV Microsoft Cloud Rains Free Services on Nonprofits The Year of Connected and Self-Driving Cars Digital Ad Fraud Could Top $7 Billion in 2016 FTC Issues Regulatory Warning on Big Data Use Cook Slams Door on Backdoor Discussions Inside E-Commerce Times Cloud Computing * Cisco Aims to Pin Down Shadow IT * US Army Marches to the Cloud * The Cloud Complexity Challenge Enterprise IT * NASA Advances Mission to Protect Earth From Asteroids * Google's Self-Driving Cars Still Need Human Touch * EFF Urges Revival of Human Rights Case Against Cisco Exclusives * HP's Marten Mickos: Open Source Is Not a Business Model * Dan Allen and Sarah White: Documentation Dearth Dooms Open Source Projects * PredictionIO's Simon Chan on Machine Learning by Devs for Devs Expert Advice * The Lego-ization of Software, or the Rise of Snap-On SaaS * Are Your Sales Tools Turning A-Performers Into B-Performers? * Customer Engagement in the Age of the Silent Traveler Hot Topics * Uber Settles With New York AG After 'Playing God' With Data * China Levels Antitrust Allegations Against Microsoft * China's Internet Tightrope Walk Marketing * What the PC Industry Could Learn From the NRA * Zuckerberg Defends Downsized Internet for Developing World * CRM Predictions: Spotting the Critical Connections Mobile * In the Shadow of the Amazon Prime Juggernaut * IDC: There's Hope on the PC Horizon * iAd Shakeup May Be in the Works Security * Phishing Attack Could Net LastPass Credentials * Microsoft Prods Skylake Users to Take the Windows 10 Plunge * Privacy as a Service Advocates Promise Better Data Protection SMB * Hats Off to Chapeau Linux's Better Fedora Concept * Surprise Success: What to Do When Sales Go Through the Roof * Sage Live Launches on Salesforce AppExchange Social Media * WhatsApp Scraps Fee Model * Foursquare Shifts Gears * Periscope's Live Streams Now Pop Up in Tweets Spotlight Features * The Future of Deliveries Will Be Driverless * Creating Rules of War for Cyberspace * Going Big: Preparing to Grow Your E-Commerce Startup Trends * Gadget Ogling: Baring Souls, Soaking Up Sound, and Tracking Babes * Legere Steps Back After Hurling F-Word at EFF * Gadget Ogling: Fitbit's Smartwatch, Super Home Movies, and Flying Machines Publications * E-Commerce Times * TechNewsWorld * LinuxInsider * CRM Buyer ECT News Network Newsletters * E-Commerce Minute * Tech News Flash * ECT News Network Weekly * Editor's Pick * Subscribe Reader Services * Account Management * Discussion * Linking Policy * Network Map * News Alerts * RSS / XML Feeds * Search ECT News Network Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Google+ [navicon-stumbleupon_20x20-gray.png] RSS Company Info * About * Advertising * Business Development * Careers * Contact * Permissions * Reprint Information Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | How To Advertise Copyright 1998-2016 ECT News Network, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Quantcast