#publisher The Economist * Log in * Register * Subscribe * Digital & mobile * Events * Topics A-Z * Newsletters * Jobs * RSS feed * Facebook * Twitter * More social links * Google plus * Linked in * Tumblr Offline reading Search this site: _______________ Search * World politics + United States + Britain + Europe + China + Asia + Americas + Middle East & Africa * Business & finance + All Business & finance + Which MBA? + Business Books Quarterly * Economics + All Economics + Economics by invitation + Economics A-Z + Markets & data * Science & technology + All Science & technology + Technology Quarterly * Culture + All Culture + More Intelligent Life + Style guide + The Economist Quiz + Book reviews * Blogs + Latest blog posts + Feast and famine + Analects + Free exchange + Americas view + Game theory + Babbage + Graphic detail + Banyan + Gulliver + Baobab + Johnson + Blighty + Lexington's notebook + Buttonwood's notebook + Newsbook + Cassandra + Pomegranate + Charlemagne + Prospero + Democracy in America + Schumpeter + Eastern approaches * Debate + Economist debates + What the world thinks + Economics by invitation + Letters to the editor * The World in 2013 * Multimedia + World + Business & economics + Science & technology + Culture + Events + The Economist in audio * Print edition * Current issue * Previous issues * Special reports * Politics this week * Business this week * Leaders * KAL's cartoon * Obituaries This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Review our cookies information for more details Internet governance In praise of chaos Governments’ attempts to control the internet should be resisted Oct 1st 2011 |From the print edition * * Tweet FOR something so central to the modern world, the internet is shambolically governed. It is run by a hotch-potch of organisations with three- to five-letter acronyms. Many of their meetings, both online and offline, are open to the public. Some—like the Internet Governance Forum, which held its annual meeting in Nairobi this week—are just talking shops. Decision-making is slow and often unpredictable. It is in short a bit chaotic. But sometimes chaos, even one that adherents like to claim somewhat disingenuously is a “multi-stakeholder” approach, is not disastrous: the internet mostly works. And the shambles is a lot better than the alternative—which nearly always in this case means governments bringing the internet under their control. In this section * Be afraid * Asia’s new model company * Faster than the speed of light * The once and future president * In praise of chaos * Many miles to go Reprints Related topics * Technology * Internet * Science and technology * Internet domains * International Telecommunication Union (ITU) Supple yet strong The internet's openness fosters two of its great virtues. First, it has encouraged innovation. In rich countries the internet has generated as much as 10% of GDP growth over the past 15 years, according to the McKinsey Global Institute, a think-tank. Second, because nobody controls the internet, it has proved hard to censor. And despite (or perhaps because of) this lack of governance, the network has proved surprisingly resilient. More than two billion people are now connected to the internet. The many predictions of collapse have not yet proved correct. Governments are uncomfortable with the current set-up. There is a growing sense—and not just among the usual authoritarian suspects—that the internet is too important, politically as well as economically, to continue to operate beyond the remit of governments (see article). Some governments are pushing to be more than mere stakeholders and instead to have the final say in important matters. China and Russia want the United Nations General Assembly to adopt an “International Code of Conduct for Information Security”. India, Brazil and South Africa have called for a “new global body” to control the internet. Other countries want to give a UN agency, the International Telecommunication Union (ITU), a supervisory role. The upcoming renegotiation of the treaty that defines the ITU's competences is regarded as an opportunity to push this agenda. Even Western governments, which usually favour the multi-stakeholder system, would like to rein in the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), whose board decides which top-level domains to add (such as .com or .biz). ICANN has just started the process to introduce a lot more high-level domains (expect to see .pepsi and .lawyer), which is why governments are increasingly nervous about the body's sometimes opaque decision-making process—and why some would like to have a veto over controversial new domains (such as .jesus, .gay and .tibet). Governments have a role to play—such as defending their citizens' interests—but they should not be allowed the final say over such matters, for creeping state control would suffocate the internet. Imagine if the ITU, a classic example of a sluggish international bureaucracy with antiquated diplomatic rituals, or indeed any other inter-governmental organisation, had been put in charge of the nascent global network two decades ago. Would it have produced a world-changing fount of innovation? We think not. From the print edition: Leaders * Recommend 154 * * Tweet * Submit to reddit * * View all comments (67) Related items TOPIC: Technology » * Network speeds: An algebraic decongestant * Space flight: Flight of the phoenix * Linn hi-fi systems: Streaming toddler TOPIC: Internet » * Babbage: December 12th 2012: Parting shots * Online privacy: Difference Engine: Nobbling the internet * Search engine optimisation: How to sell Botox to Panda TOPIC: Science and technology » * Demography: The convergence of the twain * Reforming macroeconomics: Claudio Borio on the financial cycle * Birthrates: It takes a decadent village TOPIC: Internet domains » * ICANN and top level domains: Dot dash * Internet domain names: .combat * Malware: The number is no longer in service More related topics: * International Telecommunication Union (ITU) * Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN) Want more? Subscribe to The Economist and get the week's most relevant news and analysis. * Print edition X Oct 1st 2011 Sep 24th 2011 Sep 17th 2011 Sep 10th 2011 * Next in The world this week X Politics this week * Next in The world this week X Business this week * Next in The world this week X KAL's cartoon * Next in Leaders X The world economy Be afraid Unless politicians act more boldly, the world economy will keep heading towards a black hole * Next in Leaders X Samsung and its attractions Asia’s new model company Samsung’s recent success has been extraordinary. But its strategy will be hard to copy * Next in Leaders X Neutrinos and relativity Faster than the speed of light What does an experiment that seems to contradict Einstein’s theory of relativity really mean? * Next in Leaders X The return of Vladimir Putin The once and future president It may bring clarity over who is in charge, but it will still be bad for Russia * Next in Leaders X British politics Many miles to go The economy is stuttering. So is the government’s reform agenda. Britain’s prime minister must... * Next in Letters X Letters On the euro crisis, university education, Obamacare, the R-word index, terminology, jobs, Christmas cards, cats v dogs * Next in Briefing X The euro crisis Is anyone in charge? A look behind the drifting and squabbling to see who is really to blame, and what they’re thinking * Next in United States X The judicial system The feeblest branch An underfunded court system weakens the economy as well as access to justice * Next in United States X Debating the Keystone XL pipeline An extra-large row A controversial pipeline looks set to go ahead, to green fury * Next in United States X Threatening shutdown The shape of things to come Rows and more rows * Next in United States X The long-term unemployed The ravages of time An intractable problem is getting worse * Next in United States X The National Slavery Museum Shackled again Snags for a memorial * Next in United States X New Orleans Counting the missing Unwelcome numbers for the Big Easy * Next in United States X American waterways Go with the flow Removing old dams benefits America’s rivers economically and ecologically * Next in United States X The death penalty Last orders The condemned in Texas can no longer choose their last meal * Next in United States X Lexington Open goal, useless strikers After Rick Perry stumbles, the Republican cry goes out for a substitute * Next in The Americas X Football in Brazil Own goals from Senhor Futebol Brazil hopes that the 2014 World Cup will boost its image, but the country’s football federation... * Next in The Americas X Protests in Bolivia Road rage The splintering of Evo Morales’s base * Next in The Americas X Energy in Chile Dancing in the dark A blackout highlights a pressing problem * Next in The Americas X Jamaica’s prime minister Golding goes The political price of an extradition * Next in Asia X The Haqqani network Snake country The Pakistani army’s complex relationship with jihadists * Next in Asia X Renewing Japan’s air force Dogfight over the archipelago A need for fighter jets pits old ties with America against new ones with Europe * Next in Asia X The death penalty in India Fatally flawed The death penalty looks broken, but India dares not scrap it * Next in Asia X South Korean politics The outsider An entrepreneur shakes up the political landscape * Next in Asia X Conservation in China Lone sharks Persuading the Chinese to give up shark’s fin soup * Next in Asia X Banyan Sledgehammers and stunned fish Globalisation with Chinese characteristics works at both corporate and national level * Next in Middle East and Africa X Democracy in sub-Saharan Africa It’s progress, even if it’s patchy Zambians have peacefully ousted their leader at the ballot box—an achievement that is no longer... * Next in Middle East and Africa X Chinese-African attitudes Not as bad as they say Zambians—and other Africans—know they must get along with the Chinese * Next in Middle East and Africa X Côte d’Ivoire On the mend The new man has made a fair start but must curb militias and cut corruption * Next in Middle East and Africa X Democracy in the Gulf Let’s take it slowly The Gulf monarchs dislike the Arab awakening but are having to react to it * Next in Middle East and Africa X Yemen’s president Yet another trick up his sleeve President Ali Abdullah Saleh refuses to give up * Next in Middle East and Africa X Israel’s opposition A lively new leader A new Labour star seeks to revive a once-dominant party’s fortunes * Next in Europe X Russia’s presidency Guess who! The news that Vladimir Putin will return to the Kremlin ends a four-year charade. The real question... * Next in Europe X Russia’s ex-finance minister His final decision One of the few competent policymakers in Russia gives up * Next in Europe X Corruption in France Bad smells A complex party-financing scandal creeps closer to the president * Next in Europe X Hungary’s government Not paid in full A new mortgage law annoys the banks, but will do little for the economy * Next in Europe X Charlemagne Keep the fire burning Why Germany seems not to want a quick fix for the euro crisis * Next in Britain X Tackling the slump Open the taps, loosen the vice A sickly economy needs more monetary ease and a little less fiscal squeeze * Next in Britain X The National Trust Power in the land Forget the trade unions: the government has made a much more powerful enemy * Next in Britain X The Labour Party The avenger Ed Miliband’s performance at Labour’s conference was ominous—mostly for his own party * Next in Britain X UK only Energy policy What the frack? Shale gas will not solve Britain’s energy problems * Next in Britain X UK only Supermarket wars Lean pickings Tesco’s price cuts may betoken weakness rather than strength * Next in Britain X UK only Health reform Honey, we shrunk the hospitals The next big row about the NHS * Next in Britain X UK only Designer drugs High society How recreational drug use—and the problems it causes—are changing * Next in Britain X Bagehot Ed’s dangerous dream The more you look at Labour’s new capitalism, the worse it seems * Next in International X Who should run the internet? A plaything of powerful nations Internet governance is under attack; it may have to mend its ways to survive * Next in International X The changing adult business At a XXX-roads The adult industry is seeking respectability—and profits * Next in Business X Amazon The Walmart of the web The internet giant’s new tablet computer fits its strategy of developing big businesses by... * Next in Business X Aviation Flight to the future Modernising creaking air-traffic systems will be a huge task * Next in Business X The fashion industry The glossy posse Catwalks in the West, action in the East * Next in Business X Plus-sized clothing Big business Flogging fashion for the fuller figure * Next in Business X A market for social-media data Sipping from the fire hose Making sense of a torrent of tweets * Next in Business X Alcohol in Africa Keep on walking Persuading Africans to switch from beer to Scotch * Next in Business X Mining in Indonesia Now you own it, now you don’t China wants coal. But digging it up is a dirty, dangerous business * Next in Business X Schumpeter The trouble with superheroes HP has appointed yet another superstar boss from outside. Bad move * Next in Briefing X Samsung The next big bet The world’s biggest information-technology firm is diving into green technology and the health... * Next in Finance and economics X Emerging markets One more such victory The emerging economies are winning the currency war. No one is celebrating * Next in Finance and economics X Financial stability in South Korea The won that got away Things are not as bad as the currency markets indicate * Next in Finance and economics X European banks Holey grail How much capital do lenders need? * Next in Finance and economics X Buttonwood Mood swings Financial markets are displaying a split personality * Next in Finance and economics X Investment and lobbying Money and politics Ask what your country can do for you * Next in Finance and economics X Tobin taxes and audit reform The blizzard from Brussels The European Commission gets busy * Next in Finance and economics X Market-making rules Abacussed A proposal to improve America’s financial markets risks hurting them * Next in Finance and economics X Economics focus Tinker, tailor Economists reconsider the merits of industrial policy, but some flaws are hard to fix * Next in Science and technology X The future of physics (1) So long, and thanks for all the quarks As an announcement is made in Europe that may shake physics to its foundations, America’s largest... * Next in Science and technology X The future of physics (2) Stretching the perimeter Physics cannot subsist on experiments alone * Next in Science and technology X Citizen astronomy A new world in your bedroom Amateur astronomers join the ranks of the planet hunters * Next in Science and technology X Psychology All power tends to corrupt But power without status corrupts absolutely * Next in Books and arts X The life of Charles Dickens Beloved bully Two welcome new biographies of Charles Dickens whose birth 200 years ago will be celebrated next... * Next in Books and arts X Julian Assange Leaker’s leak * Next in Books and arts X The Obama White House A cantankerous crew * Next in Books and arts X New thriller Death and the machine * Next in Books and arts X Fighting al-Qaeda Talking to terrorists * Next in Books and arts X Contemporary art Weird alleyways of culture A show in London by Grayson Perry, potter-extraordinary * Next in Obituary X Tiger Pataudi King of Indian cricket Mansur Ali Khan Pataudi, last Nawab of Pataudi and captain of India, died on September 22nd, aged 70 * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Overview * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Output, prices and jobs * Next in Economic and financial indicators X The Economist commodity-price index * Next in Economic and financial indicators X R&D spending * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Trade, exchange rates, budget balances and interest rates * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Markets * Next in Economic and financial indicators X Effective tax rates * Print edition X Oct 1st 2011 Oct 8th 2011 Oct 15th 2011 Oct 22nd 2011 From the print edition Oct 1st 2011 * Comment (67) * Print * E-mail * Reprints & permissions * Advertisement Latest blog posts - All times are GMT [_0000_schumpeter.png] The Economist explains: Why does Michael Dell want to take his company... Schumpeter 16 mins ago [_0004_babbage.png] Babbage: February 6th 2013: Scaled down Babbage 2 hrs 30 mins ago [_0010_buttonwood.png] Investing: Timing the market Buttonwood's notebook 3 hrs 7 mins ago [_0019_daily-chart.png] Daily chart: The price is height Graphic detail 3 hrs 41 mins ago [pome_tile.png] Tunisia’s shrines: Puritans on the attack Pomegranate 3 hrs 25 mins ago [_0011_democracy-in-america.png] Presidential voting: Moving the goalposts Democracy in America February 6th, 16:02 [_0000_schumpeter.png] Johnson & Johnson's faulty hips: Swinging all the way to the... Schumpeter February 6th, 14:10 More from our blogs » Most popular * Recommended * Commented Recommended * The next supermodel 1The Nordic countriesThe next supermodel * 2The World Economic Forum: A tale of two Davoses * 3Northern lights * 4The World Economic Forum in Davos: Leaders without followers * 5Islam and science: The road to renewal Commented * The next supermodel 1The Nordic countriesThe next supermodel * 2Russian politics: The Kremlin's new Anti-Americanism * 3Republicans and Latinos: Immigration reform is not enough * 4China and North Korea: On the naughty step * 5Italian politics: Gaffe or provocation? Sponsored by Advertisement Products & events Stay informed today and every day Get e-mail newsletters Subscribe to The Economist's free e-mail newsletters and alerts. Follow The Economist on Twitter Subscribe to The Economist's latest article postings on Twitter Follow The Economist on Facebook See a selection of The Economist's articles, events, topical videos and debates on Facebook. Advertisement Classified ads IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.fmsq/pfw6/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 531011;pos=button1;sz=125x125;tile=18;ord=341404510? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.fmsq/pfw6/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 531011;pos=button2;sz=125x125;tile=19;ord=341404510? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.fmsq/pfw6/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 531011;pos=button3;sz=125x125;tile=20;ord=341404510? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.fmsq/pfw6/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 531011;pos=button4;sz=125x125;tile=21;ord=341404510? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.fmsq/pfw6/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 531011;pos=button5;sz=125x125;tile=22;ord=341404510? IFRAME: http://ad.doubleclick.net/adi/teg.fmsq/pfw6/a;subs=n;wsub=n;sdn=n;!c=21 531011;pos=button6;sz=125x125;tile=23;ord=341404510? * About The Economist * Media directory * Advertising info * Staff books * Career opportunities * Subscribe * Contact us * Site index * [+] Site Feedback * Copyright © The Economist Newspaper Limited 2013. All rights reserved. * Accessibility * Privacy policy * Cookies info * Terms of use * Help Quantcast