Puttnam warns of creeping Americanisation in UK TV | Media | MediaGuardian Turn autoplay off Turn autoplay on Please activate cookies in order to turn autoplay off Jump to content [s] Jump to site navigation [0] Jump to search [4] Terms and conditions [8] Edition: UK US Sign in Mobile Your profile Your details Your comments Your clippings Your lists Sign out Mobile About us About us Contact us Press office Guardian Print Centre Guardian readers' editor Observer readers' editor Terms of service Privacy policy Advertising guide Digital archive Digital edition Guardian Weekly Buy Guardian and Observer photos Today's paper The Guardian G2 features Comment and debate Editorials, letters and corrections Obituaries Other lives Sport Subscribe Subscribe Subscribe to the Guardian iPhone app iPad edition Kindle Extra Guardian Weekly Digital edition All our services The Guardian Media User comments News Sport Comment Culture Business Money Life & style Travel Environment Tech TV Video Dating Offers Jobs News Media Media business Puttnam warns of creeping Americanisation in UK TV Share Tweet this Email Owen Gibson MediaGuardian , Wednesday 31 July 2002 13.09 BST Puttnam: changes let Ofcom fight media's 'big beasts' Selling off Channel 5 or ITV to a US company would lead to the creeping Americanisation of TV schedules, Lord Puttnam's influential parliamentary committee warned today as it outlined explicit reasons for opposing government plans to relax TV ownership laws. It said the government has gone too far with controversial proposals in the communications bill to scrap restrictions on American companies such as Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation buying UK broadcasters. While accepting that commercial considerations would ensure a US owned broadcaster could not flood the market overnight with foreign programming, the committee warned the damage would be tangible, albeit subtle. The government plans to liberalise ownership rules to allow non-EU companies snap up ITV, Channel 5 or radio groups such as GWR or Capital through new legislation designed to come into force next November. But the committee pointed out that the four basic arguments behind the government's reasoning were "lacking in force". The four reasons given by supporters of the reforms are: they would strengthen management in British TV; investment would benefit broadcasting in the same way as it had in other industries such as the car sector; foreign owners are generally benign as proven by RTL's ownership of Channel 5; audience preferences and tough regulations would safeguard quality of programming. Lord Puttnam's committee argued that broadcasting was fundamentally different from other industries because US broadcasters would be able to dominate through a pool of ready-made content. Although today's report wasn't explicit on programming, Lord Puttnam was clearly referring to fears that British schedules would be further swamped by US shows such as ER, Ally McBeal, CSI, Law And Order and 24. "We would not wish to characterise this as 'dumping'; rather what is more likely is a determined and sophisticated attempt - backed by enormous marketing expense - to shift the balance of regulatory expectations away from domestic content produced primarily with a British audience in mind, towards a more internationally focused product mix," it said. "The inescapable reality is that a US media company investing in the United Kingdom would be concerned every bit as much with enhancing the wider market value of its domestic content as with increasing its return on investment in the British based market place," the report added. The joint media select committee, chaired by Lord Puttnam, concluded that the decision by the culture secretary, Tessa Jowell, to recommend the restrictions be lifted was based on "largely unproven expectations". Despite the committee's recommendations, Ms Jowell has continually argued that she is determined to lift the restriction as part of Labour's commitment to improving inward investment. "The policy in the bill is not lightly arrived at. We believe it to be right for broadcasting, for the public, for the wider industry and for the country as a whole. Under this government, Britain is open for business," she said earlier this month at a Westminster forum for broadcasters and MPs. Critics argue that the government's determination to force the rule change onto the statute books is a sop to Rupert Murdoch in return for his UK newspapers, including the Sun and the Times, adopting a softer line towards Europe in the run-up to a possible referendum. Ms Jowell had told the committee there was "general support" for lifting the restriction on foreign ownership. But the committee said her arguments were "lacking in force" and the level of support was "more balanced" than both Ms Jowell and the trade and industry secretary, Patricia Hewitt, had argued. Print this Share Contact us Send to a friend Sender's name Recipient's email address Your IP address will be logged Share Short link for this page: http://gu.com/p/5kzz StumbleUpon reddit Tumblr Digg LinkedIn Google Bookmarks del.icio.us livejournal Facebook Twitter Contact us Contact the Media editor editor@mediaguardian.co.uk Report errors or inaccuracies: userhelp@guardian.co.uk Letters for publication should be sent to: letters@guardian.co.uk If you need help using the site: userhelp@guardian.co.uk Call the main Guardian and Observer switchboard: +44 (0)20 3353 2000 Advertising guide License/buy our content Article history About this article Puttnam warns of creeping Americanisation in UK TV This article was published on guardian.co.uk at 13.09 BST on Wednesday 31 July 2002 . Media Media business · Communications Act 2003 · Television industry Share Tweet this Email We Own The Weekend Celebrate the Guardian and Observer Weekend by signing up to receive £1 off the Saturday Guardian and £1 off the Observer for two weekends. Watch our video and get your vouchers Today's best video Tigers play with snowmen at safari park Four Siberian Amur tigers enjoy heavy snow at Longleat in Wiltshire PSV Eindhoven miss three chances in a row from two yards Dutch giants beaten 3-1 by lowly PEC Zwolle Hilary Mantel on adapting her novels for the stage Wolf Hall and Bring Up the Bodies author on RSC collaboration Elk dodges traffic on Moscow motorway Animal dodges rush-hour cars on busy ring road in Russian capital Media Network Enterprise mobility is about enabling value, not value engineering When it comes to cost and productivity, is mobile IT spend a burden, or is it an opportunity to get the most out of your staff? Benjamin Robbins argues in favour of mobile IT Media Network Lance Armstrong's reputation and the reaction of sponsors Following Lance Armstrong's confession, Leigh Crestohl explains why sponsors need to carefully manage the potential reputational risks involved in sponsoring athletes More from our Media network On Media Most viewed Latest Last 24 hours 1. National Television Awards: Ant and Dec win 12th year in a row 2. Mary Beard suffers 'truly vile' online abuse after Question Time 3. Nigella Lawson's had a belly full of photoshopping 4. Website hosting abusive Mary Beard comments closes 5. Al-Jazeera advertises 100 job posts in New York and Washington More most viewed Last 24 hours 1. Alcohol licences may be granted in secret, warn regional publishers 2. Google, Facebook and Twitter may 'face EU defamation and privacy cases' 3. Clumsy and cack-handed? Lefties are leaders, not losers 4. Mrs Brown's Boys set for fourth series, reveals creator Brendan O'Carroll 5. Metro.co.uk's month-on-month traffic dips by a third after relaunch All today's stories This week's bestsellers 1. Examined Life by Stephen Grosz £11.99 2. What Has Nature Ever Done for Us? by Tony Juniper £7.99 3. Heaven on Earth by Sadakat Kadri £7.99 4. Play it Again by Alan Rusbridger £15.19 5. Steve Biddulph's Raising Girls by Steve Biddulph £10.39 Search the Guardian bookshop Search Sponsored feature Top stories in this section Top videos Most popular Today in pictures BBC Sports Personality of the Year – in pictures Bradley Wiggins capped his remarkable sporting year by taking home the big prize at the ceremony in London Dinner, dusk and dancing Russians: my best winter shot A glass of wine with a rough sleeper, Santa in trunks, a thousand partying Muscovites … in a My Best Shot special, top photographers pick the image that sums up winter for them Monkey adopts kitten – in pictures Kimon, an eight-year-old pet female long-tailed monkey, treats a kitten as her baby in Bintan Island, Indonesia Hot topics Leveson inquiry Phone hacking Privacy & the media Newspapers & magazines News International License/buy our content | Privacy policy | Terms & conditions | Advertising guide | Accessibility | A-Z index | Inside the Guardian blog | About us | Work for us | Join our dating site today © 2013 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved. Share Tweet this