#Culture » There's nothing wrong with Americanisms: it's management-speak that is the enemy of English Comments Feed [p?c1=2&c2=6035736&cv=2.0&cj=1] Culture RSS Feed dcsimg Monday 21 January 2013 | Blog Feed | All feeds Website of the Telegraph Media Group with breaking news, sport, business, latest UK and world news. Content from the Daily Telegraph and Sunday Telegraph newspapers and video from Telegraph TV. ___________________ Submit * Home * News * World * Sport * Finance * Comment * Blogs * Culture * Travel * Life * Fashion * Tech * Dating * Offers * Jobs * Film * Music * Art * Books * TV and Radio * Theatre * Dance * Opera * Photography * Hay Festival * Video * In the Know Blogs Home » Culture » History » Allan Massie Allan Massie Allan Massie is a Scottish writer who has published nearly 30 books, including a sequence of novels set in ancient Rome. His non-fiction works range from a study of Byron's travels to a celebration of Scottish rugby. He has been a political columnist for The Scotsman, The Sunday Times and The Daily Telegraph and writes a literary column for The Spectator. [ImageHandler.ashx_.jpeg] There's nothing wrong with Americanisms: it's management-speak that is the enemy of English By Allan Massie Literature Last updated: May 29th, 2012 Comment on this Comment on this article Cupcakes? Or fairy-cakes? Who cares? Cupcakes? Or fairy-cakes? Who cares? A study of childrenâs writing by the Oxford University Press suggests that our language is being Americanised. Of course English as spoken here and as spoken in the USA have always played off each other â understandably â and the influence of American films and, in the case of children and adolescents, American comics has been noticed for a long time. Orwell was writing about it in the 1930s. Sometimes of course what is regarded â with disapproval? â as American usage turns out to be something once usual in English as spoken or written here. One example is the American habit of saying âI guessâ where we might say âI thinkâ. To anyone who objects to this, you should quote Chaucer, who used âI guessâ in the American style. The examples of Americanisation culled by the researchers from OUP look pretty thin. Children apparently now write about cupcakes rather than fairy-cakes. Well, apart from the fact that cupcakes (or cup-cakes, as Chambers English Dictionary has it) are nothing new, I donât think they are the same as fairy-cakes, which, as I remember, are little sponge-cakes which have a butter-cream topping with a slice of sponge inserted in it at an angle. If children write about a âtuxedoâ rather than a âdinner jacketâ (and presumably think of a DJ as a disc-jockey rather than a garment), one may concede that this is an example of an American usage replacing a British one, and the only surprise is that they should be writing about the article of clothing in the first place. Actually I think some of us would reserve the word âtuxedoâ â more commonly âtuxâ â for a white dinner jacket. It comes incidentally from âa fashionable club at Tuxedo Park in New York". Again one may concede that writing âsidewalkâ rather than âpavementâ represents the adoption of an American usage â though surely an unobjectionable one â but some of the other examples they give are not really American at all. A âgarbage truckâ may be an American term, but âgarbageâ as an alternative to ârubbishâ or ârefuseâ is not exclusively American, any more than âtruckâ for âlorryâ is, even if more common in the States. Chambers English Dictionary is a good guide, because Chambers has always taken an interest in American English. The 1872 edition included an eight-page appendix of Americanisms, printed in small type, three columns to the page. Nowadays it notes âU.S.â or âesp. U.S.â, if a word is more commonly found in American rather than English usage. However, quite often you find âdial.â â that is, dialect â âand U.S.â. This suggests that a word found in some British dialect has been carried across the Atlantic and become standard usage there. This is the case with âsnuckâ, used as the past tense of âsneakâ, and cited by the OUP researchers as an example of American infiltration. It would be equally true to say the word has been repatriated. Two other examples they offer as âsmartâ in the sense of âcleverâ and âcrankyâ meaning âirritableâ. I should have thought that âsmartâ has always been used in this sense here, as in âsmartyâ, âsmart-alecâ and âsmarty-pantsâ, while Chambers offers âcrossâ as one of the meanings of âcrankyâ. Be that as it may, there is nothing that should worry us about this sort of American infiltration of the language. Not only is a colloquial Americanism likely to be lively, useful and agreeable; it is often an English word or expression that has fallen out of use here and is now restored to us. The American language we really should guard against is the management-speak promoted by business schools to baffle outsiders. Unfortunately this has been seized on so enthusiastically by bankers, businessmen and bureaucrats here that we donât question its origins. Colloquial American is splendidly alive; management-speak is an abomination, an offence against the first purpose of language, which is to communicate meaning. Tags: americanisms, chambers english dictionary, English, language Recent Posts * Don't worry, Dan Brown sceptics: his codes, symbols and conspiracies will be forgotten in a few years January 17th, 2013 9:19 Comment on this * About time we lost the law against insult: we'd have had to lock up Dr Johnson and Groucho Marx, otherwise January 16th, 2013 11:00 Comment on this * Everyone enjoys a really savage review (except the subject). But there are certain rules to be observed January 11th, 2013 7:28 Comment on this * It's worth teaching imperial measures in school, not least to remind children of the old ways January 10th, 2013 14:10 Comment on this * Enoch Powell was no fascist. But it's not ridiculous for an author to imagine him in a pro-Nazi government January 7th, 2013 11:41 Comment on this Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus. comments powered by Disqus Culture bloggers * Lucy Jones * Stephen Hough * Allan Massie * Adams * James Rhodes * Xanthe Clay * Stephen Bayley * Damian Thompson * Harry Mount * Michael White * Neil McCormick * James MacMillan * Guy Stagg Culture categories * Architecture * Art * Design * Fashion * Film * Food and Drink * History * Lifestyle * Literature * Music * Photography * Political cartoon * Radio * Society * Sport * Theatre * TV Culture Tags Barack Obama BBC BBC Proms Beatles Beethoven bob dylan Bono Chopin christianity Christmas David Bowie David Cameron Ed Miliband electronica ENO Film gordon brown Kate Middleton Lady GaGa Liszt literature london Michael Jackson Music Nick Clegg Olympics Oxford Paul McCartney photo competition Photography photojournalism Pope Benedict XVI Prince William Rachmaninov radiohead Royal wedding science Simon Cowell Steven isserlis Tchaikovsky the queen Tony Blair twitter U2 X Factor ON THE CULTURE BLOG * The Pope's right – Latin is the perfect language for Twitter * Blood, gore and sponge-cake mark John Tomlinson's resumption of his chest-wig as The Minotaur * Don't worry, Dan Brown sceptics: his codes, symbols and conspiracies will be forgotten in a few years * About time we lost the law against insult: we'd have had to lock up Dr Johnson and Groucho Marx, otherwise * The Drawing Board: A day off politics Archives [Select Month..] Culture Topics * X-Factor * BBC Proms * Bafta Awards * Oscars Back to top * HOME * News * World News * Obituaries * Travel * Health * Jobs * Sport * Football * Cricket * Fantasy Football * Culture * Motoring * Dating * Finance * Personal Finance * Economics * Markets * Fashion * Property * Crossword * Comment * Blogs * My Telegraph * Letters * Technology * Gardening * Telegraph Journalists * Contact Us * Privacy and Cookies * Advertising * Fantasy Football * Tickets * Announcements * Reader Prints * * Follow Us * Apps * Epaper * Expat * Promotions * Subscriber * Syndication © Copyright of Telegraph Media Group Limited 2013 Terms and Conditions Today's News Archive Style Book Weather Forecast