The Way We Ate: The Americanization of The State Dinner - NYTimes.com Home Page Today's Paper Video Most Popular Edition: U.S. / Global Search All NYTimes.com Dining & Wine World U.S. N.Y. / Region Business Technology Science Health Sports Opinion Arts Style Fashion & Style Dining & Wine Home & Garden Weddings/Celebrations T Magazine Travel Jobs Real Estate Autos November 24, 2009, 11:38 am The Way We Ate: The Americanization of The State Dinner By MICHELE HUMES David Scull/The New York Times Joseph Chvatal, a butler at the White House, counts place settings in preparation for the state dinner for Boris Yeltsin hosted by Bill Clinton in 1994. For more than a century and a half, The New York Times has been recording the pleasures and prejudices of the American palate. “The Way We Ate” is a weekly tasting menu of vintage food writing from the Times archives, with an extra installment this week in honor of tonight’s state dinner at the White House. Woodrow Wilson loved fried chicken. Benjamin Harrison couldn’t get enough Smithfield ham . Lyndon Johnson liked chili, spoonbread and Texas barbecue, and didn’t care who knew it. Despite our presidents’ homegrown tastes, White House state dinners have almost always been distinctly French in flavor. Even the Kennedys, who made a point of serving American wines on state occasions, never thought to pair them with American cooking. Blame Thomas Jefferson. Craig Claiborne did, at any rate. In 1961, Claiborne, then the New York Times food editor, pointed a loving finger at the Francophile founding father, who introduced boeuf à la mode and veal estouffade to the White House—and set the tone, described here in an 1884 Times piece , for nearly 200 years of state dinners: An old time Virginia cook is good enough for every day, and in many respects can’t be beaten, but only a Frenchman can devise the variety and the extensive ornamentation necessary on state occasions. If a regime of Chateaubriand and Camembert was just fine by Mr. Claiborne, it didn’t sit so well with Julia Child. Eager to see the nation’s burgeoning culinary culture get its due, America’s own French Chef became the first prominent critic of Frenchified state dining. Writing for The Times in 1977, Ms. Child appealed to the incoming first lady, Rosalynn Carter, to “make White House entertaining more American.” It wouldn’t be too hard, she promised; it was really just a question of “packaging”: A quiche aux crevettes becomes an open-faced tart of Louisiana shrimp, a filet de boeuf is a prime tenderloin of Texas steer. Though her tone was lighthearted, her message was clear: Every course of a state dinner is an opportunity to showcase the nation’s edible bounty; don’t let it go to waste. Since the Carters, state dinner menus have no longer been written in French. But Child wouldn’t truly get her wish until, in a decision that seemed as much health-related as political, the famously fat-averse Clintons banished rich French sauces from the White House. Tonight, President Obama hosts his first state dinner, honoring Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. Our well-established national cuisine no longer needs any particular boost from the White House, freeing the Obamas to devise a menu that is American in a more nuanced sense of the word. We don’t yet know what will be served, though there have been murmurs of curry. But we do know who will be doing the cooking: the Ethiopian-born, Swedish-raised, naturalized American, Marcus Samuelsson. The melting pot, it seems, has finally absorbed the state dinner. Restaurants , Barack Obama , Craig Claiborne , Marcus Samuelsson , state dinner , The Way We Ate , White House Related Posts From Diner's Journal The State Dinner Menu Marcus Samuelsson To Cook White House State Dinner? The Way We Ate: Too Old to Tiki? The Way We Ate: Fear of Garlic The Way We Ate: The Year Harry Truman Passed on Pumpkin Pie Previous Post Tavern Creditors Say the City Is Hurting Their Interests Next Post Murray’s Cheese Will Open 50 Locations in Kroger Markets Search This Blog Search Previous Post Tavern Creditors Say the City Is Hurting Their Interests Next Post Murray’s Cheese Will Open 50 Locations in Kroger Markets Follow This Blog Facebook Twitter RSS Inside Diner's Journal Restaurants Drinking Cooking January 22, 2013 Dining Calendar Events about food and drink throughout New York. January 18, 2013 Weekend Fare Food-related events around New York. More From Restaurants » January 22, 2013 Modestly Sweet Wines for Spicy Super Bowl Snacks Capsaicin, the active ingredient in hot chiles, is a tricky match with wine. Sweet wines, well balanced with zesty acidity, are exceptions. January 4, 2013 Brooklyn Brewery Is on Tap for Stockholm The mystique of Brooklyn, and its beer, alight on Stockholm’s harbor. More From Drinking » January 18, 2013 The Many Ways to Clean a Leek Leeks usually come from the market full of soil. January 11, 2013 Spices: When to Grind, When to Toast Save the whole spice grinding for special occasions. More From Cooking » January 18, 2013 The Many Ways to Clean a Leek Leeks usually come from the market full of soil. January 11, 2013 Spices: When to Grind, When to Toast Save the whole spice grinding for special occasions. More From Cooking » About Diner's Journal Diner’s Journal embraces news and opinion about recipes, wine, restaurants and other matters culinary. Contributors include Eric Asimov , Melissa Clark , Glenn Collins , Susan Edgerley, Florence Fabricant , Patrick Farrell , Jeff Gordinier , Elaine Louie , Julia Moskin , Robert Simonson , David Tanis , Emily Weinstein , Pete Wells and others. Visit us on Facebook » Follow us on Twitter » E-mail us with tips and suggestions. » Subscribe to our feed » Diner's Journal Loading Twitter messages... Recent Posts January 24 What We’re Reading A collection of links from the reporters and editors of the Dining section. January 23 What We’re Reading A collection of links from the reporters and editors of the Dining section. January 22 Are You a Master of Cheese Description? If you've got a favorite cheese, and a fragrant way with words, we here at the Dining section invite you to submit your wittiest description. January 22 Front Burner Each week, Florence Fabricant recommends what you should read, taste, covet, order, cook, give and more. January 22 Dining Calendar Events about food and drink throughout New York. Follow The New York Times » Facebook Twitter .html','WT.ti','Follow-NYT-YouTube','WT.z_dcsm','1')">YouTube RSS Blogroll Adventures in Eating A Hamburger Today Amateur Gourmet Anthony Bourdain: No Reservations Bento.com Big City Country Boy Cake Spy Cannelle et Vanille Cheap Ass Food Chocolate and Zucchini Chow Dorie Greenspan Eating China Eating in Translation Gerry Dawes's Spain Gonzo Gastronomy Hunter Angler Gardener Cook Joey in Astoria Making Sunday Sauce Midtown Lunch Serious Eats Shut Up Foodies Slashfood Slice Tartelette The Gurgling Cod Chef and Critic Blogs Alan Richman Anthony Bourdain: No Reservations Chef Mateo Blog Cook's Tour by Alison Cook David Tanis Eric Ripert: Avec Eric Francois Simon: Simon Says Gael Greene: Insatiable Critic Jean-Georges Vongerichten's blog Cooking 101 Cookbooks Alinea at Home Amateur Gourmet Baking Bites Cake Spy Can You Stay for Dinner Cannelle et Vanille Chocolate and Zucchini Culinate Cured Meats David Tanis Dorie Greenspan Eating China Epicurious Epicurious: The Epi-Log Food Perestroika Food Wishes Food52 Fork and Bottle Herbivoracious Homesick Texan Hunter Angler Gardener Cook Ideas in Food Just Hungry Making Sunday Sauce Mark Bittman Melissa Clark Michael Ruhlman Not Eating Out in New York Patricia Wells Pinoy Cook/Home Cooking Rocks! Seattle Food Geek Serious Eats Slashfood Smitten Kitchen Stay At Stove Dad Tartelette The Daily Meal The Food Section The Kitchn The Wednesday Chef Food politics Civil Eats Edible Geography Food Politics by Marion Nestle Obama Foodorama Politics of the Plate Forum Chowhound Coffee Forums eGullet Serious Eats Print, Broadcast and Web Media Sites Bloomberg: Dining Bon Appetit Bon Appetit Blogs CBC News: Food Bytes Chicago Tribune: Dining Daily Telegraph: Food and Drink Dishing Eat Me Daily Eatocracy Edible Queens: World's Fare Blog Epicurious: The Epi-Log Food & Wine Food & Wine: Mouthing Off Food News Journal GQ: Forked & Corked Guardian Food New York Daily News: Food NPR Topics: Food Salon: Food Saveur The Atlantic: Food The Houston Press: Eating...Our Words The Los Angeles Times: Food The New York Times: Dining The San Francisco Chronicle: Food The Stew The Wall Street Journal The Washington Post Restaurants Bloomberg: Dining Eater National Eater New York Feast Gayot New York Restaurant News Gothamist Food Grub Street Inside Scoop SF Midtown Lunch The Feed: Time Out New York The Food Section Village Voice: Fork in the Road Waiter Rant Well Done Fillet Zagat Buzz Wine and Other Drinks Alice Feiring Appellation Beer Ardent Spirits Beer Advocate Bigger Than Your Head BrewSauce Brooklyn Guy's Wine and Food Blog CataVino Coffee Forums CoffeeGeek Daily Grape Decanter.com Dr. Vino DrinkBoy Drinkster Fermentation Fine Wine Diary Fork and Bottle Gang of Pour Gerry Dawes's Spain Gonzo Gastronomy Good Grape Grape Radio Jancis Robinson Jeremy Parzen's blog Jim's Loire Learn Italian Wines Malt Advocate Matching Food and Wine New York Cork Report Oenologic Off the Presses -- Robert Simonson Oliver Strand's coffee blog On the Wine Trail in Italy One Thousand Bars and Beyond Palate Press Prince of Pinot RateBeer Reflections on Wine Ristretto Robert Parker Online (subscription required) Rockss and Fruit Samantha Sans Dosage So You Want to Be a Sommelier Steve Heimoff The Gray Report Vinography Wine Anorak Wine Berserkers Wine Cellar Insider Wine Diarist Wine Disorder Wine Doctor Wine Spectator (subscription required) Wine Talk Wine Terroirs Wine-Life Zester Daily Archive Select Month January 2013 December 2012 November 2012 October 2012 September 2012 August 2012 July 2012 June 2012 May 2012 April 2012 March 2012 February 2012 January 2012 December 2011 November 2011 October 2011 September 2011 August 2011 July 2011 June 2011 May 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 January 2011 December 2010 November 2010 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 June 2010 May 2010 April 2010 March 2010 February 2010 January 2010 December 2009 November 2009 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 April 2009 March 2009 February 2009 January 2009 December 2008 November 2008 October 2008 September 2008 August 2008 July 2008 June 2008 May 2008 April 2008 March 2008 February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007 September 2007 August 2007 July 2007 June 2007 May 2007 April 2007 March 2007 February 2007 January 2007 December 2006 November 2006 October 2006 September 2006 August 2006 July 2006 June 2006 May 2006 April 2006 March 2006 February 2006 © 2013 The New York Times Company Site Map Privacy Your Ad Choices Advertise Terms of Sale Terms of Service Work With Us RSS Help Contact Us Site Feedback