#The New Yorker Close [NYR_300x250.gif] Close Subscribe to The New Yorker The New Yorker Skip to content Subscribe to New Yorker Subscribe to The New Yorker [USEMAP:NYR_global_header.gif] * Subscribe * home * New Yorker magazine articles * Blogs * Audio & Video * Reviews of New York events: Goings on About Town * New Yorker Cartoons * New Yorker Topics * Complete New Yorker Archives and Digital Edition * reporting * talk * fiction * Arts * Search * Services * Festival * Festival * Contact __________________________________________________________________ * Table of Contents * Humor * News Desk * Culture Desk * Fiction * Apps * Steve Jobs * State of the Union * Football * The Political Scene * Table of Contents * Shouts & Murmurs * The Talk of the Town * Comment * Ask the Author * Daily Comment * News Desk * Culture Desk * Sporting Scene * Photo Booth * Back Issues * John Cassidy * The Political Scene * Fiction Podcast * TNY Shorts * Peter Schjeldahl on Art * DVD of the Week * New Yorker Out Loud * The Political Scene Podcast * Audio Edition * The Theatre * Night Life * Art * Dance * Classical Music * Movies * Readings and Talks * Above and Beyond * New Yorker Festival * This Week's Slide Show * Animated Cartoons * Roz Chast * Editor's Desk * Shouts & Murmurs * The Cartoon Bank * Politics * Business * Culture * Health * Books * Movies * Fiction * Poetry * Table of Contents * Apps * Complete Archive * Covers * Back Issues * Contributors * THE NEW YORKER OUT LOUD * The New Yorker Store * POLITICS * PROFILES * THE TALK OF THE TOWN * COMMENT * Table of Contents * The Financial Page * News Desk * The Political Scene * Comment * The Financial Page * Hendrik Hertzberg * Close Read * News Desk * Politics * Profiles * Contributors * The Book Bench * The Fiction Podcast * Fiction Q. & A. * Culture * Contributors * Susan Orlean * Profiles * Books * Movies * Art * Music * The Book Bench * Photo Booth * Peter Schjeldahl on Art * Tables for Two * Table of Contents * Profiles * Humor * News Desk * Culture * Fiction * Table of Contents * Apps * Digital Revolution * 2012 Election * AFTER 9/11 * Home * THE NEW YORKER FESTIVAL * Friday Schedule * Saturday Schedule * Sunday Schedule * Tickets * Book Signings * Blog * App * Twitter * The New Yorker Festival * Home * The New Yorker * Reporting & Essays Annals of Innovation Small Change Why the revolution will not be tweeted. by Malcolm Gladwell October 4, 2010 Social media can Social media can't provide what social change has always required. * * * * Print * E-Mail * Single Page Related Links Ask the Author: Join a live chat with Malcolm Gladwell about social media on Wednesday, September 29th, at 3 P.M. E.T. Keywords Twitter; Facebook; Civil-Rights Movement; Revolutions; Activists, Activism; Iran; Technology At four-thirty in the afternoon on Monday, February 1, 1960, four college students sat down at the lunch counter at the Woolworth's in downtown Greensboro, North Carolina. They were freshmen at North Carolina A. & T., a black college a mile or so away. "I'd like a cup of coffee, please," one of the four, Ezell Blair, said to the waitress. "We don't serve Negroes here," she replied. The Woolworth's lunch counter was a long L-shaped bar that could seat sixty-six people, with a standup snack bar at one end. The seats were for whites. The snack bar was for blacks. Another employee, a black woman who worked at the steam table, approached the students and tried to warn them away. "You're acting stupid, ignorant!" she said. They didn't move. Around five-thirty, the front doors to the store were locked. The four still didn't move. Finally, they left by a side door. Outside, a small crowd had gathered, including a photographer from the Greensboro Record. "I'll be back tomorrow with A. & T. College," one of the students said. By next morning, the protest had grown to twenty-seven men and four women, most from the same dormitory as the original four. The men were dressed in suits and ties. The students had brought their schoolwork, and studied as they sat at the counter. On Wednesday, students from Greensboro's "Negro" secondary school, Dudley High, joined in, and the number of protesters swelled to eighty. By Thursday, the protesters numbered three hundred, including three white women, from the Greensboro campus of the University of North Carolina. By Saturday, the sit-in had reached six hundred. People spilled out onto the street. White teen-agers waved Confederate flags. Someone threw a firecracker. At noon, the A. & T. football team arrived. "Here comes the wrecking crew," one of the white students shouted. By the following Monday, sit-ins had spread to Winston-Salem, twenty-five miles away, and Durham, fifty miles away. The day after that, students at Fayetteville State Teachers College and at Johnson C. Smith College, in Charlotte, joined in, followed on Wednesday by students at St. Augustine's College and Shaw University, in Raleigh. On Thursday and Friday, the protest crossed state lines, surfacing in Hampton and Portsmouth, Virginia, in Rock Hill, South Carolina, and in Chattanooga, Tennessee. By the end of the month, there were sit-ins throughout the South, as far west as Texas. "I asked every student I met what the first day of the sitdowns had been like on his campus," the political theorist Michael Walzer wrote in Dissent. "The answer was always the same: `It was like a fever. Everyone wanted to go.' " Some seventy thousand students eventually took part. Thousands were arrested and untold thousands more radicalized. These events in the early sixties became a civil-rights war that engulfed the South for the rest of the decade--and it happened without e-mail, texting, Facebook, or Twitter. The world, we are told, is in the midst of a revolution. The new tools of social media have reinvented social activism. With Facebook and Twitter and the like, the traditional relationship between political authority and popular will has been upended, making it easier for the powerless to collaborate, cooerdinate, and give voice to their concerns. When ten thousand protesters took to the streets in Moldova in the spring of 2009 to protest against their country's Communist government, the action was dubbed the Twitter Revolution, because of the means by which the demonstrators had been brought together. A few months after that, when student protests rocked Tehran, the State Department took the unusual step of asking Twitter to suspend scheduled maintenance of its Web site, because the Administration didn't want such a critical organizing tool out of service at the height of the demonstrations. "Without Twitter the people of Iran would not have felt empowered and confident to stand up for freedom and democracy," Mark Pfeifle, a former national-security adviser, later wrote, calling for Twitter to be nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize. Where activists were once defined by their causes, they are now defined by their tools. Facebook warriors go online to push for change. "You are the best hope for us all," James K. Glassman, a former senior State Department official, told a crowd of cyber activists at a recent conference sponsored by Facebook, A. T. & T., Howcast, MTV, and Google. Sites like Facebook, Glassman said, "give the U.S. a significant competitive advantage over terrorists. Some time ago, I said that Al Qaeda was `eating our lunch on the Internet.' That is no longer the case. Al Qaeda is stuck in Web 1.0. The Internet is now about interactivity and conversation." These are strong, and puzzling, claims. Why does it matter who is eating whose lunch on the Internet? Are people who log on to their Facebook page really the best hope for us all? As for Moldova's so-called Twitter Revolution, Evgeny Morozov, a scholar at Stanford who has been the most persistent of digital evangelism's critics, points out that Twitter had scant internal significance in Moldova, a country where very few Twitter accounts exist. Nor does it seem to have been a revolution, not least because the protests--as Anne Applebaum suggested in the Washington Post--may well have been a bit of stagecraft cooked up by the government. (In a country paranoid about Romanian revanchism, the protesters flew a Romanian flag over the Parliament building.) In the Iranian case, meanwhile, the people tweeting about the demonstrations were almost all in the West. "It is time to get Twitter's role in the events in Iran right," Golnaz Esfandiari wrote, this past summer, in Foreign Policy. "Simply put: There was no Twitter Revolution inside Iran." The cadre of prominent bloggers, like Andrew Sullivan, who championed the role of social media in Iran, Esfandiari continued, misunderstood the situation. "Western journalists who couldn't reach--or didn't bother reaching?--people on the ground in Iran simply scrolled through the English-language tweets post with tag #iranelection," she wrote. "Through it all, no one seemed to wonder why people trying to coordinate protests in Iran would be writing in any language other than Farsi." ILLUSTRATION: SEYMOUR CHWAST "Small Change" continues Page ____________________ of 5 Next > Last >| View as a Single Page To get more of The New Yorker's signature mix of politics, culture and the arts: Subscribe Now Search newyorker.com (Submit) Go Most Popular MOST E-MAILED This Issue This Issue * Steve Coll: Obama's Iran problem. * Ian Parker: A gay freshman and the online world. * Sasha Frere-Jones: Lana Del Rey's fixed image. * Ben McGrath: Yoga gets hotter. * Jacob Sager Weinstein: "Before the Movie Begins" THE MAGAZINE: FEBRUARY 6, 2012 Table of Contents | Online Archive | iPad Subscribe to The New Yorker Tablet Editions Follow Us Follow The New Yorker on Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, Google + iTunes, Foursquare, RSS IFRAME: http://www.facebook.com/plugins/activity.php?site=www.newyorker.com&wid th=300&height=350&header=true&colorscheme=light&font&border_color&recom mendations=true Newsletters * [ ] This Week: Links to articles and Web-only features in your inbox every Monday. * [ ] Cartoons: A weekly note from the New Yorker's cartoon editor. ____________________ (Submit) Podcasts Podcasts * Fiction writers read favorite stories, author interviews, a weekly political roundtable. Subscribe via iTunes Feeds Feeds * Keep up with The New Yorker and newyorker.com using your favorite RSS reader. Available to subscribers via the complete archive. More From The New Yorker Cartoons of the Year A special issue, on newsstands now. The "Goings On" App What to do in New York City, for Apple and Android mobile devices. iPad, Kindle, and Nook Editions Get every story, every cartoon, every Monday. Audio Edition Subscribe to a weekly download of selected articles from the magazine, at Audible. The Complete Archive, 1925-2011 A Web-based archive of issues from our first to this week's. "Meals Worth the Trip" The latest of "The New Yorker Reader" iPad anthologies. Animated Cartoons on the Go Download the app from the iTunes store. The Cartoon Bank License or buy prints of your favorite New Yorker cartoons. On the Town Exclusive events and offers from The New Yorker's advertising and promotion department. * About Us * Contact Us * Newsletters * Blogs * Archive * Press Center * RSS Feeds * Subscription Services * Careers * New Yorker Store * Reprints/Permissions * The New Yorker Media Kit Conde Nast Digital More news, politics, culture, business, and technology: * Architectural Digest * Golf Digest * GQ * Vanity Fair * Wired Subscribe to a magazine: [Subscribe to a magazine____] Visit our sister sites: [Visit our sister sites_____] Registration on or use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy (Revised August 1, 2011). The New Yorker (c) 2012 Conde Nast Digital. All rights reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Conde Nast Digital. Ad Choices [ad_choices_arrow.png] msext