#Yahoo! Answers: Answers and Comments for Which is better branding an icon like nike swoosh or a brand mascot like Geico? * New User? Sign Up * Sign In * Help * Yahoo! * Mail * My Yahoo! * News * Finance * Sports Yahoo! Answers Search ____________________ (Web Search) Web Search * Ask * Answer * Discover [043007_alt_minidm_home_garden.gif] Search for questions: ________________________________________ Search Advanced Search My Profile 1. Home > 2. Business & Finance > 3. Advertising & Marketing > 4. Other - Advertising & Marketing > 5. Resolved Question fishead209 fishead2... Member since: January 11, 2008 Total points: 116 (Level 1) * Add to My Contacts * Block User Resolved Question Show me another » Which is better branding an icon like nike swoosh or a brand mascot like Geico? We're considering branding our new company with a mascot like Geico lizard or Redbull. Others feel an icon like Nike swoosh or Logofont like Google is better. Looking for any feedback that can help decide. * 2 years ago Report Abuse CHARITY G by CHARITY G Member since: February 19, 2007 Total points: 25104 (Level 7) * Add to My Contacts * Block User Best Answer - Chosen by Voters Will your logo require animation . . . will lifelike features benefit your advertising campaign? For instance, there isn't anyway to personalize an insurance company so they came up with something that would talk on behalf of the company. * 2 years ago 50% 2 Votes * 0 Rating: Good Answer * 0 Rating: Bad Answer * Report Abuse * 0 stars - mark this as Interesting! * Email * Comment (0) * Save + Save to Yahoo! Bookmarks + Add to My Yahoo! + Add to Del.icio.us + RSS There are currently no comments for this question. * You must be logged into Answers to add comments. Sign in or Register. Other Answers (6) Show: [All Answers............] Go * Aziz S by Aziz S Member since: July 28, 2006 Total points: 157 (Level 1) + Add to My Contacts + Block User I believe an icon is better because it will last a lot longer. Meaning that mascots sometimes get forgotten. The Gieco lizard is beginning to lose it's grip because people got tired of it. And who was that company with the duck? Think back and see how many mascots you can remember compared to icons. Union 76 changed it's revolving ball which was sort of like a mascot, to a flat icon. Many such examples can be found. I say stick to an icon. + 2 years ago 0% 0 Votes + 0 Rating: Good Answer + 0 Rating: Bad Answer + Report Abuse * dosmasdos5 by dosmasdo... Member since: May 11, 2007 Total points: 122 (Level 1) + Add to My Contacts + Block User I think you are confused. One thing is your logo and the other thing are brand mascots. A brand is configured by the following elements: - Name - Logo (the graphic representation of the name) - Isotype (the graphic representation of an object, that's an icon. Example, McDonald's "M" or Nike's swoosh) - Chromatism (your brand colors) and Graphic Elements (the elements you use to re-inforce your brand) So, Geico's logo isn't the lizzard. But Red Bull's logo are 2 energetic Red Bulls, but the Red Bulls is the brand isotype. Ronald McDonald is not McDonald's logo, it's a graphic element. I think that to figure that out you need to hire a professional who can help you to figure this out. Send me an email if you need more help on this. I work in the Brand & Creative department of one of the top 30 brand of the world. + 2 years ago 25% 1 Vote + 0 Rating: Good Answer + 0 Rating: Bad Answer + Report Abuse * David T by David T Member since: October 21, 2006 Total points: 14356 (Level 6) + Add to My Contacts + Block User Look at McDonald's for instance. Every little kid knows the "Golden Arches." They may not be old enough to read, but they know that sign stands for quality food in a fun atmosphere. It's the same with any institution. Sure the reason Geico uses a Geko is because the name familiarization. You see a lizzard speaking with a british accent and you automatically know it's Geico. You have to find something that is not only eye catching, but something that people will remember your company by. Marketing your business can be done either by catchy phrases like DLP It's the mirrors. or Wendys with their guys in the Wendy's hair wig. What did Taco Bell use? A chihuahua with a sense of humor. (Taco Bell really messed up when they canned the dog) You Querro Taco Bell was etched in the minds of millions. Source(s): Marketing/Advertising Sales Rep for five years. + 2 years ago 0% 0 Votes + 0 Rating: Good Answer + 0 Rating: Bad Answer + Report Abuse * slipstreamer by slipstre... Member since: July 01, 2006 Total points: 29141 (Level 7) + Add to My Contacts + Block User A decent logo. The swoosh has more impact, the lizard is a gimmick an somewhat lame. Mascots, unless incorporated into the logo, tend to fade away as tastes/the market changes. Go with a solid logo design or logotype. People remember and then dismiss a mascot - the cycle is pretty quick. + 2 years ago 0% 0 Votes + 0 Rating: Good Answer + 0 Rating: Bad Answer + Report Abuse * C V by C V Member since: January 04, 2008 Total points: 10392 (Level 6) + Add to My Contacts + Block User I think it depends on the image your company would like to project. The Nike logo is elegant and simple, and thus lends itself to under-stated placement. This is important, because they place it on all of their products, and people might not buy the products if they had a gaudy logo. The Geiko lizard is all about putting a humorous, friendly face on an insurance company. However, I personally felt less certain about Geiko because of the lizard; it made me think they might not be a safe company because they were being frivolous. This seems to have worked with them, and scored a hit with younger people (was that their target audience?) If you can afford it, hire a marketing company to do the testing for you so you hit your market. If you can't, at least do some informal testing before you decide. Good luck. + 2 years ago 25% 1 Vote + 0 Rating: Good Answer + 0 Rating: Bad Answer + Report Abuse * heyteach by heyteach Member since: December 01, 2007 Total points: 12492 (Level 6) + Add to My Contacts + Block User They're different functions. The Nike swoosh, for example, is spare and goes on the product, in the ads, etc. and the public knows what it is linked to. When Nike does ads, the swoosh is there BUT they get BUZZ from things like having Michael Jordan endorse their brand. That he also does Hanes and has done McDonald's (the famous commercial with Byrd) doesn't hurt them--because of his greatness in basketball the tie-in works. In another decade, however, only real fans of the sport will really know who Michael Jordan is. (Trust me I had a talk with a guy who is good at baseball and wants to play major league. I said I don't follow it but really respected people like Lou Gehrig. He said, Who? Come on, the "Iron Man" whose record was brought up time and again for most consecutive games.) Anyway, if you have a logo you can use that forever or update it some (see Betty Crocker). With things like Geico's gecko, you get a campaign. The public likes it, but you will notice Geico has other campaigns and the gecko is NOT in those (the thing with using celebs is probably getting more airplay now than the gecko). Geico doesn't have a gecko on its letterhead or such that I've noticed. So what if you pick something for an ad campaign and it bombs? Ouch. Get a simple graphic logo and you can run with that for decades. You can have both--like Nike: logo on everything and you run campaigns with the right folks. + 2 years ago 0% 0 Votes + 0 Rating: Good Answer + 0 Rating: Bad Answer + Report Abuse Open Questions in Other - Advertising & Marketing * What are some fake, scamming, bogus advertisements? * Could you please answer the survey questions?Just type one answer per question. It's for my marketing plan.? * Where could I post and ad looking for a distributor? * is marketing a good field to go in? Resolved Questions in Other - Advertising & Marketing * What do you think of this guy on craigslist? * Any idea what companies might be paying for ad words? * Calvin Klein used a commercial called "The Great Gatsby" to advertise what product? * Is there free online classified in singapore to post a garage sale? Ready to Participate? Get Started! ADVERTISEMENT Click Here Categories * All Categories + Business & Finance o Advertising & Marketing # Other - Advertising & Marketing # Search Engine Optimization Who found this interesting? Be the first person to mark this question as interesting! Sponsor Results Do You Have Coffee Teeth? An Underpaid, Overworked Single Mom Reveals $4 Teeth... News13KDTV.com GEICO Car Insurance GEICO could save you over $500 on car insurance. Get a free... www.GEICO.com Geico Read reviews for this business with directions, offers and more Tucson.Citysearch.com See your message here... Answers International * Argentina * Australia * Brazil * Canada * China * France * Germany * Hong Kong * India * Indonesia * Italy * Japan * Malaysia * Mexico * New Zealand * Philippines * Quebec * Singapore * South Korea * Spain * Taiwan * Thailand * United Kingdom * United States * Vietnam * en Español Yahoo! does not evaluate or guarantee the accuracy of any Yahoo! Answers content. Click here for the Full Disclaimer. Help us improve Yahoo! Answers. Send Feedback Copyright © 2009 Yahoo! Inc. All Rights Reserved. * Copyright/IP Policy - * Privacy Policy - * Terms of Service - * Community Guidelines * - Safety Tips