Marseille: Europe's most dangerous place to be young

Away from its glamorous tourist centre, 15 men have died this year as the city's drug war spirals out of control. John Lichfield reports

To understand Marseille catch a bus – bus number 30 from the Bougainville metro station. The route starts at the northern terminus of the metro system, five kilometres from the city centre. It winds past motorways, factories, unofficial rubbish tips and a 10th-century monastery.

France's second city sprawls for another 10 kilometres over ridge after ridge of limestone hills. Each is crowned by a white citadel gleaming in the Mediterranean sunshine which, as the bus approaches, turns into a group of shabby tower blocks.

Up to the 1960s, these were the scrubland and the hard-scrabble villages of the Marcel Pagnol novels set in the early part of the century. Fragments of the Provençal villages can still be seen. The "garrigue", or scrub, survives on the jagged mountains which crowd in from the east. But Marius, Jean de Florette and Manon des Sources and their descendants have long gone. My fellow passengers on the 45-minute ride to La Savine, one of the northernmost estates, are a blend of North Africans, Africans, Asians and Roma.

The bus passes through the poorest districts of the poorest city in France. Almost 40 per cent of people who live here are below the poverty line, compared to 26 per cent in Marseille as a whole and 15 per cent nationally. In the richer, mostly white, areas south of the city centre, the risk of dying before the age of 65 is 23 per cent below the national average. In north Marseille, it is 30 per cent higher than the French average.

If you are a teenage boy or young man from northern Marseille, you risk dying long before the age of 65. Fifteen young men, mostly from the city's northern districts, have been shot dead this year as part of a war for the lucrative franchise to sell drugs – mostly cannabis and cocaine – to the people from the wealthier parts of the city and the suburbs.

In fact, there have been almost as many killings of young men in the first nine months of 2012 as in the whole of last year. Proportionally, Marseille (population 800,000), now has almost as many drug-related murders as New York (population 8,000,000). Eyeing the issues, the French government has announced emergency action this month to stop the city, which will be the "European capital of culture" from January, from claiming title of the European capital of youth murder.

At the end of the bus ride to La Savine, I met Rachida Tir, leader of the estate's resident's association. "For seven years now we have been losing our young men," she said. "This is not just about drug trafficking. That alone cannot explain the killing."

"There is a suicidal instinct, a desperation in some of these boys. It starts with failure and rejection at school and the lack of jobs. They see no future. They live for the present, in a world of easy money and, now, violence."

Earlier this month, Samia Ghali, the mayor of the 15th and 16th arrondissements of Marseille, which embrace most of the poor northern districts, detonated a verbal bombshell. She said that the drug-related violence in northern Marseille had become so extreme that only the army could defeat it. She called on the government to deploy troops to confiscate the cheap automatic weapons flowing in from the Balkans and North Africa and to interrupt a drug trade which is, she says, conducted with impunity.

Ms Ghali, a child of northern Marseilles like Zinedine Zidane and Eric Cantona, admits that her proposal was mostly a "cry of alarm". "I was born and grew up here. I know what I'm talking about," she said. "I can no longer stomach seeing children that I have known since they were born drilled with holes. I cannot forget the distress of the girlfriend of [a recent victim] who found him shot 30 times. It is time to stop the massacre." Ms Ghali, a Socialist, berates the attitude of some politicians and commentators – including the centre-right mayor of Marseille Jean-Claude Gaudin - who dismiss the murders as "règlements de compte" ("tit-for-tat killings" or "a turf war"). "By using that kind of language, you're saying that these murders – and murder is the right word – are separate from polite society or the law," she said. "You are saying, 'let them kill each other'." Back in the busy, friendly centre of Marseille – a different planet from Bougainville and La Savine – I met Laurent Gaudon, a lawyer who has represented families of the victims. He also disputes the phrase "turf war". "Often it is not clear why these kids are dying," he said. "In one case I had last year a boy of 17 was shot because he had been disrespectful to another young man. The killer wanted to prove that he was tough enough to be in a drug gang." Marseille has always had gangland killings, Mr Gaudon said. "This is the city of the French Connection. All the organised crime of the Mediterranean basin passes through here – Corsicans, Sicilians."

In the late 1990's the police dismantled the biggest of the old crime gangs. Since then the kids in the poorer estates have gradually taken over the local drugs trade. "The old gangsters had a code of honour but not the new ones," Mr Gaudon said. "The kids can buy guns for next to nothing and they use them for next to nothing."

Ms Ghali's call for military intervention was dismissed as absurd by local and national politicians of Left and Right. It was, all the same, hugely successful. Within days, the government had drawn up an action plan to "rescue Marseille". The interior minister, Manuel Valls, and justice minister, Christiane Taubira, were in the city last week to set up a new "priority security zone" in the northern districts. There are to be 230 extra police officers and – for the first time in any French city other than Paris – a proper city police chief or "Prefect de Police". The Prime Minister, Jean-Marc Ayrault, has also promised the city the political and economic weight it needs to become a thriving "mediterranean metropolis".

The population within the city boundary is relatively poor. Many richer people – the great grand-children of Jean de Florette and Manon des Sources – have moved out to the suburbs. This is the reverse of the usual French pattern where the cities are well-heeled and the inner suburbs poor and troubled.

Mr Ayrault this week appointed another Prefect with the Herculean brief to dissolve local political jealousies and create a single, political and economic agglomeration, reconnecting Marseille with its rich satellite towns. He might begin by trying to dissolve the boundary between first and third worlds which begins at Bougainville metro station. "We have been abandoned. Forgotten," said Rachida Tir. "Most people here want to live decent, legal lives. But what choices do they have?"

A local mayor said that the drug-related violence was so extreme only the army could defeat it

Drug war in numbers

26: Percentage of people in Marseille who live below the poverty line, against 15 per cent nationally.

15: The number of men, mostly from northern districts, shot dead in the city's drug wars.

300: The number of Kalashnikovs reportedly intercepted in Marseille this year.

Sport
Michael Clarke of Australia and James Anderson of England exchange words
ashes 2013-14Bad tempered end to England's Brisbane humiliation

Arts & Entertainment
Jenna Coleman and Matt Smith in 'The Day of the Doctor'
television Aliens, queens, and too many Doctors to count –avid Whovian John Rentoul is in Tardis heaven
Sport
Sergio Aguero of Manchester City celebrates his second goal
footballHOW many? Manchester City condemn Tottenham to worst Premier League defeat since 1996

Arts & Entertainment
Pegg has been teetotal since turning 40: 'I feel like, 'Ooh, I may have dodged a bullet there.' It wasn't enhancing my life in any way'
arts + ents... but then does so anyway
VIDEO
Arts & Entertainment
She, which features Scarlett Johansson only in voice
film Actress plays Siri-like computer program in new film Her
News
Vinnie Jones ha revealed he has skin cancer
PeopleFilm star and former football hardman faces 'toughest opponent'
Life & Style
Capturing those magic moments: Simmy Richman with his son
GiftsWhy more of us are putting our faces (and our kids) on presents
News
File: Conrad Murray at his involuntary manslaughter trial in the death of Michael Jackson, 25 October 2011
PeopleConrad Murraysays star may have given himself accidental overdose
Sport
Froch may have mocked Groves' credentials for sharing the same ring during the acrimonious big-fight build-up and appeared to believe he was due an easy and enjoyable night - but it proved anything but
boxingControversy as referee ends Froch-Groves fight in ninth round

Extras
indybest
Arts & Entertainment
music Oh come, all ye songsters: Contenders ranked and reviewed
Voices
voicesHoward Jacobson: We should make unrealistic demands of the young
Sport
Points made: Olivier Giroud celebrates opening the scoring
football Arsenal striker takes advantage of showboating by Southampton goalkeeper Boruc
Life & Style
Mark's fridge clear-out brunch hash
food + drink Mark Hix reveals how you can make your food go further
Voices
voices Paul Vallely: The PM has a chance to rescue some of his green credentials and revitalise the countryside - but his record suggests his mind is elsewhere
Voices
Technology will never replace the people who look after the elderly
voices Hamish McRae: Britain was meant to have sunk by now – and the developed world along with it
Arts & Entertainment
Horrible History: It was while staying at the Villa Diodati, on the shores of Lake Geneva, that Mary Shelley was inspired to write Frankenstein
books The enduring fascination of Frankenstein's creation
Extras
indybest
Independent
Travel Shop
Classical Spain
Seven days from £599pp Find out more
Seville, Granada and Malaga Break
7 nights from only £549pp Find out more
Pompeii, Capri and the Bay of Naples
Eight days half-board from £719pp Find out more
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Designer/Developer (.NET,HTML5,JAVASCRIPT,UI,UX)

£30000 - £40000 per annum + Bonus+Benefits+Package: Harrington Starr: Designer...

Audit Manager - Financial Services

£50000 - £60000 per annum + Benefits: Pro-Recruitment Group: Audit Manager - F...

Implementation Consultant - Front office, OMS

£60000 - £80000 per annum + BONUS + BENEFITS: Harrington Starr: My client is l...

Business analyst - credit, fixed income, CDS, credit default

£60000 - £75000 per annum + BONUS + BENEFITS: Harrington Starr: Business analy...

Day In a Page

The hilarity and horror of two months inside: Greenpeace Arctic 30 activist Frank Hewetson reveals how he coped in a Russian prison

The hilarity and horror of two months inside

Greenpeace Arctic 30 activist Frank Hewetson reveals how he coped in a Russian prison
Cyclists vs motorists: A phoney war between two tribes who should be on the same side

Cyclists vs motorists

A phoney war between two tribes who should be on the same side
Jeremy Scahill: From pursuing Washington over its secret war on terror to becoming a rebel fighter in the global war against journalism

‘Homeland’ – the prequel

The reporter who has pursued Washington over its secret war on terror has become a rebel fighter in a new conflict – the global war against journalism
Gareth Bale: Cristiano Ronaldo is not a rival at Real Madrid – he is the best

Gareth Bale:

Cristiano Ronaldo is not a rival at Real Madrid – he is the best
10 action women of the year... But who will be No 1?

10 action women of the year...

But who will be No 1?
Cardboard Boxes That Look Like David Cameron: BuzzFeed - the website changing the way the world consumes news

The Buzzfeedification of news

You can laugh all you like at its lists but BuzzFeed is deadly serious
Story of mythical marine creature takes top prize at Cumbria's World's Biggest Liar competition

Mike Naylor is world’s best liar – that’s the truth

Jonathan Brown goes along to a talent show where honesty is the worst policy
Tory MP Mark Pritchard, the al-Qa’ida hunter, and a £154-an-hour contract that could become a security issue

The MP, the al-Qa’ida hunter, and a contract that could become a security issue

Tory Mark Pritchard receives fees from US intelligence firm while holding security positions in Parliament
Revealed: Arnon Milchan - the Hollywood producer behind hits Pretty Woman, Fight Club and LA Confidential who became a real-life James Bond

The Hollywood producer who became a real-life James Bond

The man behind such hits as ‘Pretty Woman’ was working secretly for Israeli intelligence on arms deals
Suzanne Collins' Hunger Games trilogy speaks to a generation of teenage readers like no other literary creation - but what’s the big message?

Suzanne Collins' Hunger Games trilogy speaks to a generation of teenage readers

But what’s the big message?
He doesn't drink. He's mates with Tom Cruise. He's cagey about who's in the new Star Wars film. Has Simon Pegg gone a bit Hollywood?

Has Simon Pegg gone a bit Hollywood?

The actor discusses life off the booze, the end of his 'Cornetto Trilogy' and why his friend JJ Abrams really shouldn't cast him in the new Star Wars film
This time it's personal: Why more and more of us are putting our faces (and kids) on presents

Christmas presents get personal

Simmy Richman reports on the rise of mugs with your mug on, keyrings with your kisser and bears with your beaming smile
Country living: Bill Granger's warming gratins

Country living: Bill Granger's warming gratins

Come winter, it's time to break out the vintage enamel oven dishes and take on the rusticity of French provincial life, says our chef
Queen cucina: Anna Del Conte - Britain's indisputable authority on Italian cooking - shares a few of her top tips

Queen cucina: Anna Del Conte

Britain's indisputable authority on Italian cooking shares a few of her top tips
Waste not, want not: Mark Hix shows how supposedly out-of-date food can be used in delicious recipes

Mark Hix cooks with supposedly out-of-date food

It’s easy to let food build up in the fridge and then throw it out when it goes past its ‘sell-by’ date. But with good planning and crafty thinking you can make your food go further